[coachkitten]

So I found two different issues that might be the one that you are talking about. The first is an issue from December 2006 with Ellen Pompeo on the cover and it has 13 insider favorites/cult products. The 13 products are Rubis Tweezers, NYX Color Trio, The beautyblender sponge, DiorShow mascara, tarte fRXtion, Bourjois Eye Shadow, Julie Hewett Noir lipstics, jordana eye liner, OPI Friar Friar Pants on Fire Nail polish, Smashbox Foundation primer, Fresh Face Palette, Cle de Peau Beaute Concealer.

The other issue was October 2007 with Keira Knightley on the cover and it had the Beloved Classics from their Best of Beauty Awards. Those products were:
Maybelline New York Great Lash Mascara, Chanel No 5, Lancome Definicils High Definition Mascara, Pantene Pro-v classic care conditioner and shampoo, Clinique Dramatically different Moisturizing lotion, Cetaphil Gentle skin cleanser, John Frieda Collection Frizz-ease hair serum, Lancome Bi-facil double-action eye makeup remover, OPI Nail Lacquer in I'm Not Really A Waitress, Helene Curtis Thermasilk Shampoo & Conditioner, Wella Liquid Hair Brillant spray gel, Cutex essential care nail polish remover pads, Phyto Phytodefrisant hair relaxing balm, Aveda Sahmpure Shampoo, Neutrogena Healthy Skin Anti-Wrinkle Cream SPF 15, Gillette Mach3 Razor, Revlon Colorstay makeup, Clinique quickliner for eyes, cover girl invisible concealer, Estee Lauder Daywear plus multi protection anti-oxidant lotion spf 15, Lancome le crayon kohl eye liner in black coffee, and Prescriptives camouflage cream.

Wow that was long! Let me know which one it is. If it is not one of those I will keep looking.