[LeeleeBell]

Does this happen after you prime or without primers? It might be the primer you are having a reaction to...a lot of people seem to find some of them too harsh (UDPP for example).

I have heard of people having an allergy to the red dye in eye shadows (purple, red, even blues have the dye in them)...they can only wear light/neutral shades. But you said you used a white one and had that reaction so that's not likely to be your issue.