[SugarAsh182]

I second BeautyMarked and Shroom, although I still haven't given up on BeautyMarked. I'm going to try using it wet or over a red base or something.

Also:
Pink Freeze -- Chalky, bleh

Parfait Amour -- Again, chalky, no color pay off

Vex -- Just looks grey on me :-/ I see no duo-chrome

Aquadisiac -- One of my very first MAC shadows... and my first swap item haha. The color pay off was just not what I was expecting

Honesty -- Pretty shimmer... but doesn't show up on me at all

Pink Venus -- Gave me horrible rabbit eyes... and I like pink shadows typically

Retrospeck -- Again, very pretty, but didn't show up on me