[IvoryLady]

I'm not as dark as you, but I'm an NC15 and the MAs give me NW15 for my undereye concealer. I think the slightly pinker tone covers my circles better than a yellow shade.

If the color is still bothering you after 2 months, I'd say go to the counter and see if there's a better shade for you, or if you can get some advice from the MAs on how to make the NW35 work better. Good luck