MAC fluidline vs. smashbox cream eyeliner?

[makeup_junkie]

Is MAC fluidline comparable to smashbox cream eyeliner? I'm curious about the fluidline because everyone here seems to love it. I have smashbox cream eyeliner in black and thunder, and well, I just don't use it that often. It's nothing fantastic in my opinion.

Does/has anyone else use the smashbox cream eyeliner and MAC fluidline? I know they are applied in a similar way and perhaps that's the thing I don't like about it...

I know I won't know for sure how I will like it until I try it myself, but I don't want to waste my money if I don't have to.

Also, does MAC fluidline have a harsh liquid-liner look?

TIA!

[Brianne]

Fluidlines stay on longer than the Smashbox liners. It doesn't have that harsh look of liquid liner - it is a very precise line (depending on the brush used and your technique of course) but it still isn't as harsh. Blacktrack is a deep inky black.

[Bubbles12_98]

I haven't tried any of the MAC fluidline, but I am recieving some Smashbox Cream EL in a swap. I hope I like them...WHat brush would you use to apply them with for a very thin line? I have never used anything other than pencil EL

[makeup_junkie]

I ordered the brush that goes with the smashbox cream liner. It's flat eyeliner brush.

[makeup_junkie]

It's comparable to the MAC 212.

[Juneplum]

moved to mac chat

[martygreene]

There is a very informative review that compares the various creme/gel liners in the reviews section: BB/Smashbox/Stila/MAC: Gel Eyeliners- comparison

[NikkiHorror]

Honestly I like Fluidline better!!

I use it with the straight, pencil-tipped Smashbox Eyeliner brush, though.

[baby_love]

I like fluidline better because you CAN (if you want to) get the liquid eyeliner look. Smashbox's creme liners aren't very creamy, and I wouldn't use them as a base like you can with fluidlines.

[prinzessin784]

The Smashbox ones are creamier, which I think is why they don't last as long as Fluidliners do. The Fluidline is more of a gel than a cream, so while they aren't as smooth in my opinion, they have much better staying power!