Black Tied or Carbon? which one should I get 4 a smokey eye ?

[nettiepoo]

I recently got shroom, all that glitters, satin tuape and twinks. The MA @ the mac store also tried black tied on me and I liked It, but i didnt get it that day, I also seen another Kool black shadow called carbon. Not sure which one I should purchase 2 go with my new stash, whataya think?



things arent always as they seem.....Or r they?

[brokenxbeauty]

I have Carbon and hardly use it... I don't like it that much. So I would try Black Tied. But I know a lot of people like Carbon as well...

[Rosalie1915]

Well carbon is a Matte black with no shimmer, while black tied is a velvet or a black with silver sparkle! I think everyone should own carbon because it is a staple but, you can find a lot of Matte black eyeshadows. so if you have a matte black all ready get Black tied

[nettiepoo]

Thanks u guys for all the info