UDPP vs. MAC Eye Prep & Prime

[kuuipo1207]

Which do you prefer and why? TIA!

Also, has any one tried any of the other Prep & Prime stuff from MAC? Would you recommend any of it or something else?

[sigwing]

I use the face and the lips P&P and like them both. I think the lip helps protect my lips from getting dried out from my long-last type lipsticks. And the face primer is good, I think cheaper than the Smashbox that I really like, and so similar I really don't notice a difference for the price.

[panda0410]

I like the P&P for lips and use it - like sigwing above it stops my lips from drying out and keeps my lippie smoother. I stopped using P&P eyes when I got my UDPP the other day which is awesome - wont ever touch another eye primer again, it will be UDPP from now on!

[amelia.jayde]

a mac artist used the eye prep & prime on me once and it creased after like three-four hours. UDPP has kept my eyeshadow from creasing for 12 hours, so i definitely prefer UDPP. i guess it depends on your skin? some people say UDPP creases for them.

[Indian Barbie]

Mac Prep+prime Eye is what I use everyday and it never creases for me. When it runs out Im gonna try UDPP.

[kuuipo1207]

OMG!! I just bought UDPP while I was on vacation in TN and I LOVE IT!! I put on makeup one day and twelve hours later when I was getting ready to take it off and go to bed, it STILL hadn't creased, sanother forumanother forumanother forumged, or budged from when I put it on!! I LOVE IT! Thanks so much guys!!

[giz2000]

I really like all of MAC's primers, except for the eye P&P...I use UDPP and love it!

[tsukiyomi]

I bought UDPP and I HATED it. It just looked like concealer when I put it on. It was okay but, meh. I'll stick to my shadesticks.

[darkbeauty27]

UDPP works just okay for me. It still creases after a few hours. I like to use TIGI After Party creme eye shadows as bases.

[Ms. Z]

I don't like he MAC primers or UDPP; they both creased and/or moved/felt sort of sticky (don't know any other way to describe it.
My preference is the Paula Dorf eye primer & Smashbox photofinish.

[BeatrixKiddo]

I've tried both and am still looking for perfect concealer/primer, all in one, that works perfect. I'll try a MAC paint or new paint pot next - alot of girls seem to have great results. Good luck and hope you find the perfect eye primer.

[Asphyxia]

I would never recommend Mac Eye prep & prime because it creases really bad. I do prefer UDPP all the way!

[pyxystixx]

Well for those who do like UDPP, I believe they are selling 2 for $25 on UD's website and I believe you can also pick them up at Ulta.

[♥MiCHiE♥]

I will not wear mascara without MAC's P&P Lash. I didn't care for the P&P Eyes. When I tried it, I creased as soon as I stepped into the TX heat. I have 3 backups of UDPP, though. I LOVE it! And, I've experimented all over with UDPP. I find that 'less is more' with it. You will crease immediately if you use too much and it settles into an eyelid crease. Seriously, you need to pull the wand out and swipe your index finger across one side for one eye; across the other side for the other eye. That's it. After a few months, you can pull the stopper out, but there will be more product on the brush, so lightly swipe your finger for each eye.

[bluebird08]

I like UDPP...

[Briar]

I love UDPP for the eyes; my shadows don't crease, smudge or budge; and MAC Prep & Prime Skin for the rest of my face. I wear mineral foundation and I've noticed my face itches a bit with any brand of mineral unless I use the P & P Skin primer. Plus, it makes my skin look more even and smooth.

[blindpassion]

I use MACS prep and prime for skin, and I LOVE it, I don't know what I did without it. UDPP is my vote for eyes though.

[AppleDiva]

I like Prep+Prime Eye for winter, when my skin is drier. Currently, I am using MAC matte gel with Paint Pots. I love this combo. I was using up to 3 primers in the summer because my lids are oilier. I think about 95% of UDPP users love it, so I would try both and see which one works for u. (maybe u can get samples of each!)

[Doowop]

mac prep and prime is not good, but i'm stuck with it as i've used it only a few times..I have oily lids and my shadows/liner still creased on me. Boo

[Twinkle_Twinkle]

There really isn't much of a comparison between UDPP and MAC's Prep & Prime for eyes. I think the P&P makes eye makeup application easier, smoother, but it doesn't keep the makeup in place the way UDPP does.

[Mrschloe]

MAC P&P is a staple for me. I have really dark eye lids and this evens the colour, smoths the skin and makes e/s look more vibrant and easier to apply. I even use it as a concealer under my eyes. Can't live without

As for UDPP, I tried liking it but I don't. Because is so shear dosen't neutralizes my dark its also to waterly and dry.

[hollytron]

No comparison, imo. UDPP all the way for me. It latches onto pigment, making the color far more vibrant, as well as allowing the color to glide on. It brightens the eyes when wore alone (I'm pale and it does for me anyway), and dries quickly so you can apply makeup quickly.

I went to a party one night, wearing some UD shadow with the PP, the next morning, my cousin visited. I hadn't showered yet or anything (just plopped into bed after the party), my hair was a mess, I was in PJs, but my makeup looked fab. My cousin asked, "Why did you do your makeup if you're just lazing around?!" I DIDN'T!

[Jade1012]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mrschloe

MAC P&P is a staple for me. I have really dark eye lids and this evens the colour, smoths the skin and makes e/s look more vibrant and easier to apply. I even use it as a concealer under my eyes. Can't live without

As for UDPP, I tried liking it but I don't. Because is so shear dosen't neutralizes my dark its also to waterly and dry.

So sorry it didn't work out for you. I was sold on it the first day I tried it. I have very oily lids and have tried them all.. MAC, SMashbox, Models Prefer.. everything! UDPP was the only one that has worked.. I had my shadow on for 16 hours and there were no creases or anything. I hope to GOD they don't ever discontinue this or I will cry! MAC Piggies go on vibrant and last all day with UDPP. They are as bright as when you use a shade stick underneath them. I recommend it to all that have oily lids.

As for Face primer.. have not tried MAC but I use BE's face primer and I have to say... my BE mineral make up looks fantastic now. Before I was always wondering if I could find something that worked better. One day I wandered into Ulta (AWESOME store btw.. a make up addicts crack house!) and saw they carried BE, found the primer and thought "WTH.. lets give it a shot" Glad I did.

Give 'em a try ladies you won't be dissapointed!

Jade

[JanineDesiree]

I could not wear eyeshadow, or even liners on my top lid.
I have tried every type of primer or whatever I was told to use as primer.

The only item to work is UDPP!!! A friend bought it for me a couple weeks ago!
Its time to buy shadows again!!

[DJ_Roxas]

I prefer UDPP beacuse I've worn it and it hasn't creased, it hasn't faded away and it really easy to get off as long as you have a make-up remover with glycerin. As for MAC P&P, I haven't tried it but I have heard horror stories about it not working so well.