Most disappointing--Idol Eyes. Maybe I should try again now I know to use a base and pat it on and I got one used so maybe someone ruined the finish but I swapped that sucker away. So pretty in the pan. So meh on the lids.
Most hated--Ego (the Starflash one, not the Peacocky one) great pigmentation, very blendable, gorgeous mid tone neutral pink, true to pan color, and made my eye look like a bunny rabbit with pink eye. So unattractive I had to swap it. It was a little too blendable, all the fall out irritated the shit out of my eyeballs and then I really had pink eye, not just looking like I had it. Serious bunny rabbit city pink eye.
Runner Up Most Hated--don't excommunicate me or anything but I love the Naked Lunch color but it was a hot shimmery mess on me and looks like total fish scales--emphasized every crepey skin contour and crows foot on my eye.lids I rename it Regurgitated Lunch. Seriously ugly on me which sucks because I love the color, the duochrome, the finish and all that. But I am not trying to look like the CryptKeeper.