MAC - Sheen Supreme Discussion - Page 9  

I can wait to buy these! They look amazing! So kissable!

I got to play with these today and wow the formula is amazing... they really reminded me of the Clinique Colour Surge Butter Shine lipsticks (which are amazing!) Supremely Confident was the one I specifically wanted to try and I found this color to be a less pigmented version of Innocence Beware (VV collection) and if you have IB you pretty much know it's not too powerful to begin with so even less is just.. well silly! For those w/o as pigmented lips it would work much better. 

Unless when I swatch them I feel otherwise I want: Behave Yourself , Full Speed (heck yeah!) Gotta Dash, Insanely It and Quite The Thing.  Good thing these are permanent.

Quote:

Originally Posted by BeautyByLele 

I dont know if its been mentioned or asked already but I called my local MAC Pro and they said you cant B2B for these lipsticks

That doesn't make sense.  The price is the same as for a lipstick.

Anyone want to tell us otherwise? Please say we can!
 

After reevaluating the swatches on temptalia I want Gotta Dash and Look at her.

On Temptalia, Gotta Dash was compared to Ravishing which I own. What is a good lipliner to use with it if anyone else owns it and can suggest one for me please :)?

yeah that sucks if there isnt b2m for these lippies :( can you b2m for pro longewear ones? if you can for those then why not these? and espcially if they are the same price! how silly!

I was so looking forward to these, but after all the swatches I'm totally confused wich one to get. I wanted the pink one (Behave Yourself?), but since it has some shimmer in it, I'm turned off. And it does look like it's difficult to apply evenly, and that it ends up in the lines easily. I'm also liking Gotta Dash and Full Speed. But Full Speed might be too bright for me, I have Toxic Tale and it looks ridiculous on me, probably the most unflattering shade I own. Hm, maybe the really light nude one could be something for me.

Behave Yourself does have shimmer in it, but it's not that noticeable.  It ends up looking more like a sheen than a bunch of sparkles.   

Anyway, here is my video overview for anyone who'd like to watch:  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fqIQra6hrdE  :)

Sheen Supreme Review

Urban Decay Naked Palette Giveaway here

www.allurabeauty.com

I have a feeling the MAC employee may have been mistaken.  I don't see why these wouldn't be B2M-able.  They're made of plastic.  The boxes they come in also say "Back 2 MAC." 
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by LMD84 

yeah that sucks if there isnt b2m for these lippies :( can you b2m for pro longewear ones? if you can for those then why not these? and espcially if they are the same price! how silly!

Sheen Supreme Review

Urban Decay Naked Palette Giveaway here

www.allurabeauty.com

Quote:

Originally Posted by Allura Beauty 

I have a feeling the MAC employee may have been mistaken.  I don't see why these wouldn't be B2M-able.  They're made of plastic.  The boxes they come in also say "Back 2 MAC." 
 

 

---

Sheen Supreme Review

Urban Decay Naked Palette Giveaway here

www.allurabeauty.com

aha! that makes since then! i guess now people can just point out what it says on the box - the box doesn't lie!!

So far I'm interested in Ultra Darling and Bare Again. Would love to B2M for them but I wouldn't be surprised if we can't as it seems like they've been cutting back more & more on what we can B2M for.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Allura Beauty 

I have a feeling the MAC employee may have been mistaken.  I don't see why these wouldn't be B2M-able.  They're made of plastic.  The boxes they come in also say "Back 2 MAC." 
 

 

---

Sheen Supreme Review

Urban Decay Naked Palette Giveaway here

www.allurabeauty.com

I thought when the box says "Back 2 MAC" that means you can use the product when it's empty to bring back 2 MAC. I didn't think it would mean that you can get that product for 6 empties.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pinkdollface 

I thought when the box says "Back 2 MAC" that means you can use the product when it's empty to bring back 2 MAC. I didn't think it would mean that you can get that product for 6 empties.

i dunno then! i thought people would only bring stuff back to mac if they were getting somethin for free out of it! otherwise you could put it in your normal recycling bin?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pinkdollface 

I thought when the box says "Back 2 MAC" that means you can use the product when it's empty to bring back 2 MAC. I didn't think it would mean that you can get that product for 6 empties.

Yep, you're exactly right. That has no bearing one way or the other on whether you can get that item as your freebie. My counter only lets me get a regular lipstick as my freebie when I turn in 6 B2M-able empties. My freestanding (before it closed) let me choose a regular lipstick, regular lipglass or e/s pot (no e/s pro pans allowed even tho they are cheaper). Both places got increasingly strict over time with letting me choose LE items whether or not they were in special packaging. And I know some people were able to get dazzleglasses as their freebies at their freestanding stores in the past, but some (if not all) places stopped doing that...mine never allowed it. So I guess we'll just have to see what happens with these new lipsticks.

Oooh, I thought what people were saying is that you can't use them as one of your 6 B2M items. My mistake!  :)
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pinkdollface 

I thought when the box says "Back 2 MAC" that means you can use the product when it's empty to bring back 2 MAC. I didn't think it would mean that you can get that product for 6 empties.

Sheen Supreme http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fqIQra6hrdE

Sheen Supreme Review

Urban Decay Naked Palette Giveaway here

www.allurabeauty.com

I wasn't sure which one I wanted but as soon as I saw Ultra Darling on Temptalia's site, I was sold! I'm seriously going to try to limit myself to one!!

i am eyeing the pink ones and maybe nudes i dont have much of those.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Winthrop44 

 

Yep, you're exactly right. That has no bearing one way or the other on whether you can get that item as your freebie. My counter only lets me get a regular lipstick as my freebie when I turn in 6 B2M-able empties. My freestanding (before it closed) let me choose a regular lipstick, regular lipglass or e/s pot (no e/s pro pans allowed even tho they are cheaper). Both places got increasingly strict over time with letting me choose LE items whether or not they were in special packaging. And I know some people were able to get dazzleglasses as their freebies at their freestanding stores in the past, but some (if not all) places stopped doing that...mine never allowed it. So I guess we'll just have to see what happens with these new lipsticks.

lol! oh yeah! i didnt think about things that way around! it was a long day yesterday ok! :p lol!
 

Temptalia has her  comparison swatches up

http://www.temptalia.com/mac-sheen-supreme-dupes-comparisons

Quote:

Originally Posted by Winthrop44 

 

Yep, you're exactly right. That has no bearing one way or the other on whether you can get that item as your freebie. My counter only lets me get a regular lipstick as my freebie when I turn in 6 B2M-able empties. My freestanding (before it closed) let me choose a regular lipstick, regular lipglass or e/s pot (no e/s pro pans allowed even tho they are cheaper). Both places got increasingly strict over time with letting me choose LE items whether or not they were in special packaging. And I know some people were able to get dazzleglasses as their freebies at their freestanding stores in the past, but some (if not all) places stopped doing that...mine never allowed it. So I guess we'll just have to see what happens with these new lipsticks.

Well i can't back 2 mac at all. The program doesn't excist in the netherlands, but i heard form a MA in Cologne that there are plans for back 2 mac coming to the netherlands! Let's hope so!
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by Allura Beauty 

Oooh, I thought what people were saying is that you can't use them as one of your 6 B2M items. My mistake!  :)
 

 

 

 

---

Sheen Supreme http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fqIQra6hrdE

Sheen Supreme Review

Urban Decay Naked Palette Giveaway here

www.allurabeauty.com

I can totally understand that you were confused. It was a confusing conversation

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mpm893 

I wasn't sure which one I wanted but as soon as I saw Ultra Darling on Temptalia's site, I was sold! I'm seriously going to try to limit myself to one!!

I'm loving Ultra Darling! Can't wait to check it out in store! I want a few colours which is annoying cause I'm on a budget this month...thank god there perm!

Now I'm not sure if I want Ultra Darling or Gotta Dash.

Sorry I was unclear but I was trying to say that the MAC employee stated that the Sheen Supreme could not be gotten as the freebie item.  The employee stated only a reg l/s, reg l/g or an regualr eyeshadow.  They are constantly changing the rules on B2M, so it can be frustrating

Quote:

Originally Posted by BeautyByLele 

Sorry I was unclear but I was trying to say that the MAC employee stated that the Sheen Supreme could not be gotten as the freebie item.  The employee stated only a reg l/s, reg l/g or an regualr eyeshadow.  They are constantly changing the rules on B2M, so it can be frustrating

if these products are permenant, and B2M is for a perm. lipstick [in the UK anyway] then are we able to get these? what was the deal with B2M for slimshines? MAC never make anything uniform or clear!

Haha, no, it was my fault.  I just read it too quickly. 

I believe it when MAC says you can't get this as one of the B2M lipsticks.  You used to be able to B2M for a whole range of lip products, even the more expensive ones, but they're pretty strict about it now.
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by BeautyByLele 

Sorry I was unclear but I was trying to say that the MAC employee stated that the Sheen Supreme could not be gotten as the freebie item.  The employee stated only a reg l/s, reg l/g or an regualr eyeshadow.  They are constantly changing the rules on B2M, so it can be frustrating

Sheen Supreme http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fqIQra6hrdE

Sheen Supreme Review

Urban Decay Naked Palette Giveaway here

www.allurabeauty.com

Quote:

Originally Posted by spunky 

if these products are permenant, and B2M is for a perm. lipstick [in the UK anyway] then are we able to get these? what was the deal with B2M for slimshines? MAC never make anything uniform or clear!

In the past I have B2M for all my Slimshines.

I'm hoping someone comes along and gives us the definitive answer. I have so many empties that are not getting brought back!  I want them gone.

Quote:

Originally Posted by RayannaBanana 

Now I'm not sure if I want Ultra Darling or Gotta Dash.

I'm really liking the looks of both of those.

Wow, I really cannot decide on which ones of these to get!  I guess I should wait for more swatches on paler skin.  =\

I kind of like Gotta Dash, but I'm wondering if it is paler, darker, or the same than Strange Potion.  I got that thinking it was going to be paler, but on my pale skin it looks kind of dark.  

I also like the looks of Can't Get Enough, Supremely Confident, and Ultra Darling.

Supremely Confident looks really pale though, I'm wondering if I can pull it off.  I'd love a comparison between it and Underage lipglass!

I like the look of Can't Get Enough, but I'm just not sure I can pull it off, it would be my first brown-toned lipstick.  

Ultra Darling looks lovely, but again I wish I could see some swatches on a paler girl!