Quote:
Originally Posted by
Honey&LemonGirl 
I actually read that it was Carthage off the NARS Facebook page. In the comments for this photo, the fans were claiming it was Schiap, but NARS replied and corrected that it was Carthage in the editorial.
I searched through Nars facebook page, and you're right. :)
I'm surprised, but there might be an explanation. It's a picture from the Jil Sanders Summer Spring 2011 runway show. And the guy who did the make up was Peter Philips, who's the global creative director at Chanel. He used Chanel products for the face and the eyes. He said he mixed a "shocking pink" lipstick (he didn't say which one) with white pigment to make it "more vibrant". If this lipstick is Nars Carthage, then the mixing with white would explain why it looks different from the swatches we've seen so far.
http://www.vogue.com/collections/spring-2011/jil-sander/beauty/
Thank you all for the pictures and links. It's very helpful for those who can't test products in stores and have to rely on swatches. :)