What acne treatment works for you?

I can only speak for Murad and ProActiv since those are the only two you mentioned that I've tried.  ProActiv seems to work for me at first but not for the long haul, which is why I gave up on it.  Gave Murad a try for about 3 months and it actually made my skin worse! HOWEVER, i'm glad I tried Murad because there were a few products that actually worked really well for me.  The clarifying toner and oil free moisturizer are both fantastic!  What ended up working for me was just mixing and matching from different brands for my specific needs.  

I've used pro-active and it worked well but when I stopped using it, it stopped working.

I love clay masks, and sulphur soap. 

Acne is very complex and there is no one fits all "cure" . I had to experiment with many products, and see how my skin reacts to various ingredients. 

Clay masks always worked for me to help with congested pores. Tea tree helped me dry out pimples (especially when you feel one coming) and sulfur soap helps dry out and battle breakouts. 

Also, I find fish oils and green drinks help tremendously to keep my skin clear.

Toner: Biore Triple Action Astringent
Acne Treatment: Benzagel Benzoyl peroxide 5%

These are my current HG skincare products. I've used proactive in high school and it worked for a while and then I tried murad which did nothing.

I even got my bf using these and its working for him. My skin stays relatively clear as long as I use it.

The cold ice, because it really helps to compress the face of disease arising out of acne. Take the ice cubes and glue and maintain acne for five minutes. This can force the pus out. Hitting the ice cooler and also the results of Acne skin can build contemporary and free of acne in no time. How can this be done every 1/2 hours to drive the most effective results.
 

Ive tried proactive and Murad and while both provided some relief short term, the only brand which I have used consistently is the pHAdvantage acne package which I got from phskincare.com