Originally Posted by Pinkdollface
I think Play it Proper is lighter.
Originally Posted by Mac-Guy
The finish is different as well as the color. PIP is certainly lighter and has more highlighting qualities whereas SA provides more sheen and slightly more pigmentation. Do you need both? Well, that depends on your level of addiction. :)
Originally Posted by martiangurll
It is worth getting both. PiP has more silver sheen to it. PiP is closer to Flower Fantasy in terms of light pink sheen though.
My level of addiction is pretty high and all pale powders are a weakness of mine, so I have a feeling Play It Proper will be coming home with me tomorrow, along with Supersweet MES and Love Cycle MES
I've also been lemming FoL l/s even though I am usually not one for bright neon pink l/s! I have WMS though. I am thinking I will be liking these bright lippies in the Spring and Summer!