MAC By Request discussion - Page 2

Quote:

Originally Posted by SNJx 

Just realised I can now have more votes a day by using my university network. I'm now voting Rocker, CoC and Jete. CYY and Moth Brown look pretty safe but I think Jete and Rocker need a bit more help :)

It's funny because Mothbrown is probably my favourite item of all of these and I haven't voted for it once. It's always been #1 among the shadows, so I figure my votes are better spent pushing Guacamole and/ or Jete. 

Quote:

Originally Posted by Anitacska 

I see Guacamole has been overtaken again. I've been busy all day, but will put in a few votes this evening. ;) Glad to see ho much closer Moxie and Rocker have got to 3N, I bet they can overtake it if we put in some elbow grease. ;)

Yeah, it's slipped a bit, but still close, considering it was last among the shadows for the first few days. 

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alisha1 

Is it me or does MAC Heavenly Bliss seem very similar to Sweet Satisfaction? Sweet Satisfaction has been on my 'to buy' list forever! 

HB looks warmer, slightly more coppery, but they are similar. Sweet Satisfaction is a beautiful neutral and I'd honestly say it would be the better option between the two.

Quote:

Originally Posted by internetchick 

I honestly have no strong feelings about what I would want to come back. It would have been nice if they had just asked for general input and then narrowed down their choices from there. There are products I want more than what is being offered.

I kind of wish they'd done stages- first round suggestions and second round shortlisted. Actually, it would have been really cool if they could have let some fans upload videos/ photos to make a case for "their" choice. But that would be complicated and this is the first time that they're trying something like this. If it goes well, I wouldn't be surprised to see them do another collection like this. 

Quote:

Originally Posted by CoolinOlympia 

I think they should just bring them ALL back!!!!  Why not???  MAC can do it!  This is just for publicity, so they should just bring them all out!!!!

Lol. That would be funny. I'd definitely be happy if they brought back all the shadows, because there are at least 4 that I want (Mothbrown, Guacamole, Jete, Solar White). 

I'm only looking forward to Rocker, CYY, & CoC to be honest.  The shadows all look dupeable or completely uninteresting.  Esp Solar White... Carefree pro longwear shadow looks so similar.  Even moth brown, I'm sure there's a pigment out there that is similar.  

That would be cool! Maybe next time they might allow more input. It doesn't really feel like a fan choice collection to me with the way they went about it.

Woh the swatches have totally changed my mind! Guac and Cool Heat are pretty dupable. At first I didnt see the big deal about Jete but after swatches I love it! So I'll be joining team jete now, wheeehooo! And I'm loving Moth Brown now. It almost reminds me of a lighter purpleish version of my beloved Hocus Pocus! I'll be voting for Jete and Moth Brown. Solar White is pretty awesome too, but mufe has a shadow really close.

I think I'm alone on my lippy choices. But I'm not feeling Moxie much. In T's swatches it pretty much looks like what party parrot looks on me. I have PP, QS, and CYY so I'm good on matte pinks right now. Rocker is pretty though, but to be honest I dont wear vampy colors much. I'm actually in love with Eden Rocks. It's more my kind on color. And dare I say I like 3N. It looks like a great nude! I have a feeling 3N, CYY, and Moxie will be the winners.

I agree with Flash to Flesh it is gorg! Cult of Cherry is such a stunning red.

So my new votes are Jete and Moth Brown e/s's, Eden Rocks and 3N l/s (I think 3N is safe so I'll be voting for ER like crazy), and Flash of Flesh and Cult of Cherry glosses

CYY, I do love it! But it kinda emphasizes yellow on my teeth. But still think its a color that everyone needs in thier stash. I saw a pic of me wearing it recently and it really is stunning. Such a pretty girlie pink

Moxie, Cool Heat, Guacamole and heavenly bliss are my current favs to come back

Good job girl!
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by MRV 

Woohoo! It's nearly up to 2nd place! :)

I would love it if we could push Rocker and Moxie up to 2nd and 3rd. I don't even care if CYY isn't in the top 3, imo it's not a must have, people might prefer Moxie instead and have 3N as the nude option.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Calla88 

Where are my Jete people ??? It's the perfect Neutral. This voting poll is going to crazy over the few days!

Jete is the one I've been voting for, along with Moxie and CoC or FoF. 

Quote:

Originally Posted by singer82 

Woh the swatches have totally changed my mind! Guac and Cool Heat are pretty dupable. At first I didnt see the big deal about Jete but after swatches I love it! So I'll be joining team jete now, wheeehooo! And I'm loving Moth Brown now. It almost reminds me of a lighter purpleish version of my beloved Hocus Pocus! I'll be voting for Jete and Moth Brown. Solar White is pretty awesome too, but mufe has a shadow really close.

 

I think I'm alone on my lippy choices. But I'm not feeling Moxie much. In T's swatches it pretty much looks like what party parrot looks on me. I have PP, QS, and CYY so I'm good on matte pinks right now. Rocker is pretty though, but to be honest I dont wear vampy colors much. I'm actually in love with Eden Rocks. It's more my kind on color. And dare I say I like 3N. It looks like a great nude! I have a feeling 3N, CYY, and Moxie will be the winners.

 

I agree with Flash to Flesh it is gorg! Cult of Cherry is such a stunning red.

 

So my new votes are Jete and Moth Brown e/s's, Eden Rocks and 3N l/s (I think 3N is safe so I'll be voting for ER like crazy), and Flash of Flesh and Cult of Cherry glosses

3N is a great nude. I think it should suite most skintones but perfect on fair-light-medium folks. However, it is not terribly unique and the also since it's a lustre, not very long lasting. I still wouldn't mind it coming back as I'm almost out of mine. It's one of those super easy nudes to wear, not as much work required as with say Myth.

I shoulda sold my Mothbrown a few month ago while it was still in demand, damn it! I never use it....

My votes are now for CoC, Jete and Rocker. I want Rocker, Moxie and 3N to win in the lipstick category

How is everyone getting multiple votes? It only lets me vote once per day

G's #2 and will continue!

Guacamole Girl

Quote:

Originally Posted by singer82 

Woh the swatches have totally changed my mind! Guac and Cool Heat are pretty dupable. At first I didnt see the big deal about Jete but after swatches I love it! So I'll be joining team jete now, wheeehooo! And I'm loving Moth Brown now. It almost reminds me of a lighter purpleish version of my beloved Hocus Pocus! I'll be voting for Jete and Moth Brown. Solar White is pretty awesome too, but mufe has a shadow really close.

 

I think I'm alone on my lippy choices. But I'm not feeling Moxie much. In T's swatches it pretty much looks like what party parrot looks on me. I have PP, QS, and CYY so I'm good on matte pinks right now. Rocker is pretty though, but to be honest I dont wear vampy colors much. I'm actually in love with Eden Rocks. It's more my kind on color. And dare I say I like 3N. It looks like a great nude! I have a feeling 3N, CYY, and Moxie will be the winners.

 

I agree with Flash to Flesh it is gorg! Cult of Cherry is such a stunning red.

 

So my new votes are Jete and Moth Brown e/s's, Eden Rocks and 3N l/s (I think 3N is safe so I'll be voting for ER like crazy), and Flash of Flesh and Cult of Cherry glosses

3N is definitely not safe sadly, get your votes in for it, Moxie & Rocker aren't that far behind.. to be honest I prefer Moxie to Candy Yum Yum, but I don't think one collection needs two matte bright pinks. 
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by Anitacska 


Moxie is catching up on Rocker, some reinforcement would be much appreciated!

I will help in an hour or so:) I need to finish some schoolwork.

Quote:

Originally Posted by baghdad81 

I voted for Jete, Moxie and CoC

Me too.  Finally got Jete to 2nd behind MB (with the help of some other insomniacs).

Quote:

Originally Posted by ROlean 

Me too.  Finally got Jete to 2nd behind MB (with the help of some other insomniacs).

That would have been me....... Jete will make it ;)
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by ROlean 

 

Me too.  Finally got Jete to 2nd behind MB (with the help of some other insomniacs).

Quote:

Originally Posted by gracie90 

That would have been me....... Jete will make it ;)
 

 

Me too :)

Teamwork! I'm glad both Jete and Guacamole are in the top 3 now:) I've been voting for Moxie the last 15 min and now it only needs 3000 votes to beat 3N. Guess we have a new goal for tonight haha.

We need to vote for Rocker too, because it MUST be in the top 3! I see Jete has overtaken Guacamole, although that's fine as they're 2nd and 3rd. Just don't let them fall behind HB! ;)
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pinkdollface 

Teamwork! I'm glad both Jete and Guacamole are in the top 3 now:) I've been voting for Moxie the last 15 min and now it only needs 3000 votes to beat 3N. Guess we have a new goal for tonight haha.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Anitacska 

We need to vote for Rocker too, because it MUST be in the top 3! I see Jete has overtaken Guacamole, although that's fine as they're 2nd and 3rd. Just don't let them fall behind HB! ;)
 

 

A lot of other people are voting for Rocker so i'm just voting Moxie. If i see Rocker needs more help i will vote for that one later. I think together we can make sure Jete and Guacamole stay 2nd and 3rd!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Anitacska 

We need to vote for Rocker too, because it MUST be in the top 3! I see Jete has overtaken Guacamole, although that's fine as they're 2nd and 3rd. Just don't let them fall behind HB! ;)
 

 

I'm game for that. CoC needs some love too. Go team.

I think I'll keep voting for Guac as well as Jete and MB. I'm crossing my fingers that Moth Brown, Jete, and Guac will be the finalists.

Moxie and Rocker is gaining up on all of them wow, you guys work fast! lol Hey it helps my wallet so keep it coming  But I think I need to see more swatches on Moxie. It's starting to creep up on me! If it wins I'll prob still pick it up. I should just give up on Eden Rocks, not enough people seem to like it. I dont see it catching up. I might just have to vote on 3N for the lippies.

Look what I helped do!

EYE SHADOW / Jeté
now has 22,020 votes!

not too crazy about any of the lipglasses, I'm more of a lipstick person anyways

I deff want Candy Yum Yum again! I only got one since I kinda snoozed on the launch date,

I don't see why it shouldn't win. Probably going to get 4 of it :]

Solar White is pretty but I have Cloudbound and it's really similar. I'd really want to get

Moth Brown, Guacamole and Heavenly Bliss eyeshadow whichever do make it