Specktra.net MAC Makeup › Forums › MAC Chat › Color Collections › MAC Heavenly creature discussion
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

MAC Heavenly creature discussion - Page 200

post #5971 of 7900
Quote:
Originally Posted by PixieDancer View Post

I've lost my MINDDDDDDD!  I backed up a MSF (LY) That I wasn't even going to get!

THEN, I received my next online order and opened my box to ANOTHER shattered MES!!  Earthly looked like someone smashed it against a tabletop 20 times!  I have NEVER seen a shadow THIS messed up!  When I called MAC to replace it, I INSISTED they send me a shipping label so I could send it back to them to show them just HOW BAD IT WAS! 

LOOK...

 

photo (2).JPG  photo (3).JPG

 

When I opened my black box I thought...  Oh wow, MAC is using new tissue paper!  Because there was gold and brown dust everywhere!

SOOOO... My HC hauling, replacing, and backing up continues!

 OMG!!  I'm glad that MAC is sending you a replacement of your MES and bubble wrapping it. I remember MAC doing bubble wraps for the mineralize products and I wonder why they stopped doing that.

post #5972 of 7900
Quote:
Originally Posted by MacAddictNurse View Post

Ok so I wanted to post this pic just because I looooveeee how great Ring of Saturn and Cut a Paper (with meteoric over it) look on me, I was originally going to pass up on cut a paper since and got it sometime during the weekend. I have nothing on my face except for some lotion and I used a very light hand I'm a NC44 and finally found a perfect nude for me. Thanx for all the advice my husband actually complemented he said I looked like I had a glow loll his a sweety :)

IMG_4239.jpg

Oh my gosh! You look fab!  I love Ring of Saturn too.  Oh and now your making me what Cut a Caper.  I didn't think it was wearable but it looks great on you.  

post #5973 of 7900
so sorry for all you ladies with your shattered things ssad.gif makes me weep..
post #5974 of 7900
Quote:
Originally Posted by Icecaramellatte View Post

Oh my gosh! You look fab!  I love Ring of Saturn too.  Oh and now your making me what Cut a Caper.  I didn't think it was wearable but it looks great on you.  

Thank you! And u know I'm really glad I didn't pass up on any of these, I think this is the best collection MAC has had in a long time, it makes me excited for the next one! I think u should go back and look at cut a paper again u might just love it too.
post #5975 of 7900
Quote:
Originally Posted by liba View Post

MES I've used the most so far: 

WATER!!! I made sure to get one without hardly any dark blue and mostly lots of the seafoam green. It comes out a really clear pastel green on me - a very 70's peacock green. Reminds me of my mother's favorite Borghese eyeshadow when I was a kid...I used to open it up and gaze at how sparkly and bright it looked.

 

I thought it was going to be a color only for nights out, but I love it so much, I just slap it on my lids for daytime, applied dry and then spritzed after with Fix+, then use a little CotU or RoS in the crease and soft brown shadow under the eye (I particularly like the brown Crushed Metal pigment from last year's Summer Stash set). I think it'll look great for daytime with Industrial pearlglide under the lower lash line too. 

 

MSF I've used the most so far:

Star Wonder!! Is it any wonder we're all using Star Wonder? It's such an easy, no brainer color for brightening up the face. It's great for a soft cheek look or underneath or on top of a stronger color. It's GORG applied over Weekend Getaway. Also GORG applied underneath Supernova, to tone it down a smidge.

 

I haven't been much in the mood for bronzer yet this year, since I still want to rock all my bright pinks and light corals from the spring, and with a deep tan, I prefer myself in reds, oranges and more mid-tone shades. CotU is so beautiful and it matches my natural tan perfectly, so I'll wind up using it as much as SW before too long - just will have to say bye bye to Flamingo, Force of Love and Reel Sexy when I wear it, unless I want a retro look (or a Jersey Shores look, lol).

 

MB I've used the most so far:

Ring of Saturn!! It's the sexy summer version of my most used blush this year - Early Morning. I love the sheen it's got, and it just lasts and lasts....this batch of MBs is even longer lasting than the Naturally ones, it seems to me. I get lots of compliments wearing it - it looks great with red lips. I REALLY need to find my missing Sail La Vie, which I'd love wearing with it. I hope it turns up soon and hasn't just been lost for good. I LOVED Bi-tone MB from a couple years ago, but this one pretty much is superior to it in every way. 

 

Lippie I'e used the most so far:

It's a three-way tie between Cusp of Dawn, Venus and Astral right now, but I haven't busted out Strictly Plutonic, Galaxy Rose or Meteoric yet. I'm honestly overloaded with lipsticks and glosses right now and am trying to cycle through everything as much as possible. I do think my favorite lipstick from HC is Cusp of Dawn, as a thoroughly modern looking nude - it's not remotely retro in any way, and I love it for that! My fave gloss hasn't been decided yet (I bought 'em all, except for Celestial Kiss, which I also almost got), but so far, Astral is the most striking. Strictly Plutonic is like last year's Krazy Kahuna, though....just "off" enough to be unusual, while not being too overdone for summertime hijinx.

 

Wow, what an awesome collection! I wish I had ten heads so I could do all the things I want to do with all the beautiful products from this one! tease.gif

 

I love the green in water too.  I can't believe I almost passed it up.  I love Ring of Saturn with Fire Sign.  I'm slowly making my way through the products.  I expect more raves on the way.  Maybe then I can pick my faves too.

post #5976 of 7900
Quote:
Originally Posted by PixieDancer View Post

I've lost my MINDDDDDDD!  I backed up a MSF (LY) That I wasn't even going to get!

THEN, I received my next online order and opened my box to ANOTHER shattered MES!!  Earthly looked like someone smashed it against a tabletop 20 times!  I have NEVER seen a shadow THIS messed up!  When I called MAC to replace it, I INSISTED they send me a shipping label so I could send it back to them to show them just HOW BAD IT WAS! 

LOOK...

 

photo (2).JPG  photo (3).JPG

 

When I opened my black box I thought...  Oh wow, MAC is using new tissue paper!  Because there was gold and brown dust everywhere!

SOOOO... My HC hauling, replacing, and backing up continues!

 

Wow.. o_O

post #5977 of 7900
Quote:
Originally Posted by ILoveMakeup84 View Post

TOday I wore Earthly (again!) and LY on top of Tarte's Dollface blush and I am officially in love with LY! It gave me such a lovely glow!
I also used an oldie, Flurry of fun l/g on top a Tarte lipsurgence and wow! Now I remember why I got BU's of FoF! Such a fun l/g greengrin.gif

I'm soooo bummed I missed out on FoF! I hope they repromote.

Pixiedancer I am so sorry about your shadow! That's unacceptable!
post #5978 of 7900
Quote:
Originally Posted by thatKanojo View Post

 

Woooo, enjoy! Your swirls look pretty funky. peace2.gif

 

This thread has been slowing down! DON'T LET IT DIE YETTTT. D: I haven't gotten my LY and SW in the mail yet. :(


Haha I haven't gotten my magnetic attraction [that I want so bad] yet either. Probably going to take the full 10 business days to get here *sigh*.

 

 

Anyway my swirls for everyone to enjoy :

 

photobucket-13140-1342069476184.jpg

 

They're a bit messy because I've been using everything. And you can barely see the swirl in solar ray because I picked such a tiny one (on purpose). I love these products so much. th_e2cloud9.gif


Edited by andabri - 7/11/12 at 10:30pm
post #5979 of 7900

me no likey my new earthsine.... it has a one thick swirl of purple and a lot of brown and gold....  haven't swatched it yet though.

post #5980 of 7900
Quote:
Originally Posted by PixieDancer View Post

 

The box was FINE!!  That's why I INSISTED MAC take this sh*t back... because it looks like it was done before shipping and then got rattled around inside the box and caused a powdery mess.  I had another MES AND a MSFN in the same box that were COMPLETELY fine!  It's the most messed up broken MES I have EVER seen!  I don't think that level of damage could have been caused during shipping without other things in the box being messed up too.  I also had a foundation and Fix+ in that box and there wasn't so much as a dent on the corners of their packaging!  Something F'ed up went down in that MAC Warehouse!


I remember someone told me before that they had a mom or sister that worked in a shipping center (not MAC specifically, I forget what company it was). And when workers were mad about something on the job or even bored, they would purposely tamper with things they were sending out to customers. Sounds ridiculous I know, but there are some crazy people in the world.

post #5981 of 7900
Quote:
Originally Posted by Prettypackages View Post

me no likey my new earthsine.... it has a one thick swirl of purple and a lot of brown and gold....  haven't swatched it yet though.


Aw, were you hoping for more of the purple? I'm in love with that color as an eyeshadow!

post #5982 of 7900

Thank you so much for the swatches, Shellcat!!! I was wondering about Venus and Gem of Roses, too. bouquet.gif

 

I went to Macy's this evening to see the collection one more time. I brought my Viva Glam Cyndi and Gem of Roses with me. Although one was slightly warmer than the other, Cyndi and Fire Sign looked closed enough on my skin. Venus was pretty. It looked similar to Lustering. (Hope I was not fooled by the store lighting. LOL) Ring of Saturn was beautiful, but I could not decide on it. I left the store empty handed.

 

 

Quote:

Originally Posted by PixieDancer View Post

I've lost my MINDDDDDDD!  I backed up a MSF (LY) That I wasn't even going to get!

THEN, I received my next online order and opened my box to ANOTHER shattered MES!!  Earthly looked like someone smashed it against a tabletop 20 times!  I have NEVER seen a shadow THIS messed up!  When I called MAC to replace it, I INSISTED they send me a shipping label so I could send it back to them to show them just HOW BAD IT WAS! 

LOOK...

 

photo (2).JPG  photo (3).JPG

 

When I opened my black box I thought...  Oh wow, MAC is using new tissue paper!  Because there was gold and brown dust everywhere!

SOOOO... My HC hauling, replacing, and backing up continues!

This is crazy! So sorry this has happened to you, PixieDancer. Glad to hear other items in the box were OK, but still, I'm speechless. Hope the replacement will arrive in a hurry. th_cheerup.gif

 

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by liba View Post

MES I've used the most so far: 

WATER!!! I made sure to get one without hardly any dark blue and mostly lots of the seafoam green. It comes out a really clear pastel green on me - a very 70's peacock green. Reminds me of my mother's favorite Borghese eyeshadow when I was a kid...I used to open it up and gaze at how sparkly and bright it looked.

 

I thought it was going to be a color only for nights out, but I love it so much, I just slap it on my lids for daytime, applied dry and then spritzed after with Fix+, then use a little CotU or RoS in the crease and soft brown shadow under the eye (I particularly like the brown Crushed Metal pigment from last year's Summer Stash set). I think it'll look great for daytime with Industrial pearlglide under the lower lash line too. 

 

MSF I've used the most so far:

Star Wonder!! Is it any wonder we're all using Star Wonder? It's such an easy, no brainer color for brightening up the face. It's great for a soft cheek look or underneath or on top of a stronger color. It's GORG applied over Weekend Getaway. Also GORG applied underneath Supernova, to tone it down a smidge.

 

I haven't been much in the mood for bronzer yet this year, since I still want to rock all my bright pinks and light corals from the spring, and with a deep tan, I prefer myself in reds, oranges and more mid-tone shades. CotU is so beautiful and it matches my natural tan perfectly, so I'll wind up using it as much as SW before too long - just will have to say bye bye to Flamingo, Force of Love and Reel Sexy when I wear it, unless I want a retro look (or a Jersey Shores look, lol).

 

MB I've used the most so far:

Ring of Saturn!! It's the sexy summer version of my most used blush this year - Early Morning. I love the sheen it's got, and it just lasts and lasts....this batch of MBs is even longer lasting than the Naturally ones, it seems to me. I get lots of compliments wearing it - it looks great with red lips. I REALLY need to find my missing Sail La Vie, which I'd love wearing with it. I hope it turns up soon and hasn't just been lost for good. I LOVED Bi-tone MB from a couple years ago, but this one pretty much is superior to it in every way. 

 

Lippie I'e used the most so far:

It's a three-way tie between Cusp of Dawn, Venus and Astral right now, but I haven't busted out Strictly Plutonic, Galaxy Rose or Meteoric yet. I'm honestly overloaded with lipsticks and glosses right now and am trying to cycle through everything as much as possible. I do think my favorite lipstick from HC is Cusp of Dawn, as a thoroughly modern looking nude - it's not remotely retro in any way, and I love it for that! My fave gloss hasn't been decided yet (I bought 'em all, except for Celestial Kiss, which I also almost got), but so far, Astral is the most striking. Strictly Plutonic is like last year's Krazy Kahuna, though....just "off" enough to be unusual, while not being too overdone for summertime hijinx.

 

Wow, what an awesome collection! I wish I had ten heads so I could do all the things I want to do with all the beautiful products from this one! tease.gif

I cannot wait to wear Star Wonder over Weekend Getaway. Thanks for the suggestion, liba! If I buy one more item from this collection, it would be Ring of Saturn. Agree, it's a sexy summer blush. It swatched beautifully on my skin. I might just settle with Light Year though. greengrin.gif

post #5983 of 7900
Quote:
Originally Posted by andabri View Post


Haha I haven't gotten my magnetic attraction [that I want so bad] yet either. Probably going to take the full 10 business days to get here *sigh*.

 

 

Anyway my swirls for everyone to enjoy :

 

photobucket-13140-1342069476184.jpg

 

They're a bit messy because I've been using everything. And you can barely see the swirl in solar ray because I picked such a tiny one (on purpose). I love these products so much. th_e2cloud9.gif

 

*drool* I can't wait until I have my whole little family together. Still, looking at your picture, SR and LY are the most eye catching to me. I know SR is my favorite MB so it'd be funny if LY ended up my fave as well. :3

 

I just love this collection so much. My fave MAC collection thus far. Left QC in the dust!

post #5984 of 7900
Quote:
Originally Posted by Richelle83 View Post

 

You are too much!! Maybe they will get the hint with the next mineralized collection go around. 

AhhAAhhhaaahHHaaa!  You KNOW it!  2 shipments in a row with one broken MES and one COMPLETELY RIDICULOUSLY SHATTERED TO DUST MES...  I had to take a stand!  Invest in bubble wrap MAC, or I will haunt you with my harrassment!  I have Specktra's back on this one!

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by ladyarwen View Post

Pixie, honey, that shit is jacked up. O_O

Ooooo TRUST ME, I feel the same way!  Crazy!  Did you get a chance to grab anything from this collection?  How's the job hunt going?!

post #5985 of 7900
Quote:
Originally Posted by peachsuns View Post

Thank you so much for the swatches, Shellcat!!! I was wondering about Venus and Gem of Roses, too. bouquet.gif

 

I went to Macy's this evening to see the collection one more time. I brought my Viva Glam Cyndi and Gem of Roses with me. Although one was slightly warmer than the other, Cyndi and Fire Sign looked closed enough on my skin. Venus was pretty. It looked similar to Lustering. (Hope I was not fooled by the store lighting. LOL) Ring of Saturn was beautiful, but I could not decide on it. I left the store empty handed.

This is crazy! So sorry this has happened to you, PixieDancer. Glad to hear other items in the box were OK, but still, I'm speechless. Hope the replacement will arrive in a hurry. th_cheerup.gif

 

 

I cannot wait to wear Star Wonder over Weekend Getaway. Thanks for the suggestion, liba! If I buy one more item from this collection, it would be Ring of Saturn. Agree, it's a sexy summer blush. It swatched beautifully on my skin. I might just settle with Light Year though. greengrin.gif

 

Me too!  I'm dieing to try it, especially after PrettyKitty's EOTD!  She enabled me to get it and I'm doing the best I cannnnn to get my paws on the darn thing!  Thanks for the th_cheerup.gif

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by andabri View Post


I remember someone told me before that they had a mom or sister that worked in a shipping center (not MAC specifically, I forget what company it was). And when workers were mad about something on the job or even bored, they would purposely tamper with things they were sending out to customers. Sounds ridiculous I know, but there are some crazy people in the world.

I COMPLETELY believe that!  Thanks for that story!  Now I don't feel quite so crazy!  Although ANY suggestion to the MAC Supervisor that it happend BEFORE shipping fell on deaf ears!  She wouldn't hear of such a thing and kept apologozing for UPS...  I swear this was not a UPS thing!  Impossible.

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by GlamQueen21 View Post

 OMG!!  I'm glad that MAC is sending you a replacement of your MES and bubble wrapping it. I remember MAC doing bubble wraps for the mineralize products and I wonder why they stopped doing that.

I have no idea!  But I have to think that this has been a huge issue!  Bubble wrap seems like cheap insurance compared to repeatedy replacing products!

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by singer82 View Post


I'm soooo bummed I missed out on FoF! I hope they repromote.
Pixiedancer I am so sorry about your shadow! That's unacceptable!

Thanks girl!  I feel that way too!  Hopefully my replacement arrives intact!

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by nikki1387 View Post

so sorry for all you ladies with your shattered things ssad.gif makes me weep..

Makes me sad too!  Poor little guy gets NO love!

post #5986 of 7900
Quote:
Originally Posted by andabri View Post


Haha I haven't gotten my magnetic attraction [that I want so bad] yet either. Probably going to take the full 10 business days to get here *sigh*.

 

 

Anyway my swirls for everyone to enjoy :

 

photobucket-13140-1342069476184.jpg

 

They're a bit messy because I've been using everything. And you can barely see the swirl in solar ray because I picked such a tiny one (on purpose). I love these products so much. th_e2cloud9.gif

WOW!  I am drooling over your Earthshine AND Star Wonder!  SO much of that nice brown in your ES... really makes it so much more wearable on medium skintones!  And that SW!!  What a fabulous swirl!  It goes on forever!  Good goodies girl!

post #5987 of 7900

Just when I thought I was done with this collection....Stratus blush managed to make it's way home with me today.

 

Also, I love Bright Moon with Fig 1 e/s.

post #5988 of 7900
Quote:
Originally Posted by ILoveMakeup84 View Post
I also used an oldie, Flurry of fun l/g on top a Tarte lipsurgence and wow! Now I remember why I got BU's of FoF! Such a fun l/g greengrin.gif

I love Flurry of Fun and sadly didn't back it up. Here's hoping it gets a repromote. It's been a while since we had some cute sparkly glitter lips in a summer collection!

 

Quote:

Originally Posted by MacAddictNurse View Post


Thank you! And u know I'm really glad I didn't pass up on any of these, I think this is the best collection MAC has had in a long time, it makes me excited for the next one!

 

It's really invigorated a lot of people towards MAC again, from what it seems. It's gotten me all hot and bothered, for sure...

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by peachsuns View Post
I cannot wait to wear Star Wonder over Weekend Getaway. Thanks for the suggestion, liba! If I buy one more item from this collection, it would be Ring of Saturn. Agree, it's a sexy summer blush. It swatched beautifully on my skin. I might just settle with Light Year though. greengrin.gif

 

Your welcome! I have been enjoying those Casual Colors. I bet Star Wonder will look awesome over Evening Stroll too.th_thdeadea.gif

 

If I had to pick one or the other, I'd pick RoS over Light Year for sure. There will be more blushes in shades similar to RoS coming up, though. 

post #5989 of 7900

I feel like to complete my haul I should also buy Earthshine, Strictly plutonic.. and take a better look at Venus and Center of the universe since everyone seems to love them^^ but I'm afraid I can't really afford everything.. september will be a month full of stuff for us (in Italy we should have By request, style seeker, ruffian)... anyway we have reached page 200 wohooooo!!

post #5990 of 7900
Quote:
Originally Posted by CartoonChic View Post

Finally uploaded my MES pics. These were all ordered online. The swatches didn't come out right, so I have to redo them tomorrow. Hopefully it won't be so cloudy and I'll have more sunlight. After playing with Sky some more, I still don't have that "happy I bought it" feeling. I don't think I'm keeping it. Any takers?

 

 

Bright Moon

Bright Moon Mineralize Eye Shadow

 

 

Earthly

Earthly Mineralize Eye Shadow

 

 

Neo Nebula

Neo Nebula Mineralize Eye Shadow

 

 

Magnetic Attraction

Magnetic Attraction Mineralize Eye Shadow

 

 

Sky

Sky Mineralize Eye Shadow

LOVE ur swirls!!!!!!!!  I think u just convinced me to get Earthly.

post #5991 of 7900

I added Earthly and Universal Appeal to my collection this week! An MUA friend picked the swirls for me and I LOVE them!

 

30c23cac.jpg

post #5992 of 7900
Quote:
Originally Posted by sherm View Post

I added Earthly and Universal Appeal to my collection this week! An MUA friend picked the swirls for me and I LOVE them!

 

30c23cac.jpg

Very nice swirls, especially your earthly love.gif Mine is kinda similar, it also contains alot of the creamy, lighter color :)

I really love purples, but i didn't pick up Universal Appeal the first time because it swatched just plain brown in the store.

Might look into it again tomorrow, maybe if i get one with alot of the purple color, we'll see ..

Anyway, enjoy your new goodies yahoo.gif

post #5993 of 7900
Quote:
Originally Posted by PixieDancer View Post

I've lost my MINDDDDDDD!  I backed up a MSF (LY) That I wasn't even going to get!

THEN, I received my next online order and opened my box to ANOTHER shattered MES!!  Earthly looked like someone smashed it against a tabletop 20 times!  I have NEVER seen a shadow THIS messed up!  When I called MAC to replace it, I INSISTED they send me a shipping label so I could send it back to them to show them just HOW BAD IT WAS! 

LOOK...

 

photo (2).JPG  photo (3).JPG

 

When I opened my black box I thought...  Oh wow, MAC is using new tissue paper!  Because there was gold and brown dust everywhere!

SOOOO... My HC hauling, replacing, and backing up continues!

I think earthly must be a sensitive MES. Mine was also shattered when I received it I took it in to a store and they exchanged it.

post #5994 of 7900

Hmm - I'm still trying to decide if I want anymore of the mes.

 

I picked up Magnetic Attraction but none of the others really called my name.

 

Universal Attraction is pretty in the pan but I wasn't too crazy about the swatch.

 

Earthy was just a bit too grey brown.

 

What are everybody's absolute fans.?

post #5995 of 7900
Quote:
Originally Posted by Fiberluver View Post

Hmm - I'm still trying to decide if I want anymore of the mes.

 

I picked up Magnetic Attraction but none of the others really called my name.

 

Universal Attraction is pretty in the pan but I wasn't too crazy about the swatch.

 

Earthy was just a bit too grey brown.

 

What are everybody's absolute fans.?

 

The better ones have more purple than the green and darker color. Also it does look better wet if there isn't much purple in it.

 

Neo Nebula became a favorite out of nowhere! 

post #5996 of 7900

I want to love Light Year but the shade and me are having a difference of option on my skin.

 

MAC_Light_Year_Mineralize_Skinfinish_3.jpg

http://www.warpaintandunicorns.com/2012/07/mac-light-year-mineralize-skinfinish.html

 

^ This is not flattering (look like I got burned lol) but I love the finish.

post #5997 of 7900
Earthly is nagging at me! But I'm trying to resist. Its it a must have for a pale brown eyed Chica with dark hair? Its my 30th birthday today, so I might just give in! But I'm also wanting a bu of Venus, so maybe i should wait until restock
post #5998 of 7900
Quote:
Originally Posted by Fiberluver View Post

Hmm - I'm still trying to decide if I want anymore of the mes.

 

I picked up Magnetic Attraction but none of the others really called my name.

 

Universal Attraction is pretty in the pan but I wasn't too crazy about the swatch.

 

Earthy was just a bit too grey brown.

 

What are everybody's absolute fans.?


My favorites are Magnetic Attraction, Neo Nebula and Invincible Light.

post #5999 of 7900
Quote:
Originally Posted by AniBEE View Post

I want to love Light Year but the shade and me are having a difference of option on my skin.

 

MAC_Light_Year_Mineralize_Skinfinish_3.jpg

http://www.warpaintandunicorns.com/2012/07/mac-light-year-mineralize-skinfinish.html

 

^ This is not flattering (look like I got burned lol) but I love the finish.

 

Wow, it's amazing how it can look pink on some and orange on another! What's your color in MAC or are you too fair? Guhh I really hope it'll work on me.

post #6000 of 7900
Quote:
Originally Posted by singer82 View Post

Earthly is nagging at me! But I'm trying to resist. Its it a must have for a pale brown eyed Chica with dark hair? Its my 30th birthday today, so I might just give in! But I'm also wanting a bu of Venus, so maybe i should wait until restock

 

happybirthday.gif 

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Color Collections
Specktra.net MAC Makeup › Forums › MAC Chat › Color Collections › MAC Heavenly creature discussion