gracie90, I am the same as you, except for the mascara (I've never liked it on me, so never wear it!).
I wore my MA MES over UD's primer potion all over the lid a couple weeks ago with Powersurge eye kohl on my lower lash line. Gorgeous, and it took all of a couple minutes to do.
I love Fire Sign lipstick on me; not red, but still really pretty. I saw a lot of folks compare it to VG Cyndi, but they are very different on me. Earthshine I am having issues with and don't know how to use it without looking ridiculous (I'm NW 5, at the most). I still need to play with my other goodies too (4 other MES, 3 CSG, LY, and SW; skipped the blushes).
I will try to take pics of my swirls and post them here in the next couple days.