Mac mattes are better than they used to be, but they still aren't amazing to me. Is Scarlett Ibis a matte? (I'm too lazy to look) I love that one, but the color also helps. YSL has Mac beat on the mattes, though. They came out with three shades a couple of months ago and they are HG lip products. I hope they expand the color range on that.
I wish there were other colors in the lipstick and shadows, but I see it fits within the Marilyn theme. I guess that's my biggest problem: I'm not into the Marilyn look. When I wear red lips I really only do mascara and maybe, maybe a little blush. I reach for red when I'm not in the mood to go all out, but I still want to make a statement. Plus, I just think my face looks fresher that way. The shadows in this collection are out! Not only because they look glittery, but they are shadow colors I don't go for.
Having said all that, though I probably will buy the Charmed and LG and probably a back up of SI to make it worth the trip. I would like to have the BP compact but not at the BP price since I have no need for the product.
