I got Complice today, and it is a lovely pale shade with what I would call gleam vs frost......it looks very light gold to me in the pan, but it swatches as a pale peachy pink - almost like a lighter version of MAC Naked Lunch on me It's very pretty. I'll compare it to Island but if memory serves, Island is deeper in tone.
I am sending the 3 polishes I ordered back......I was trying to like Frenzy but it does NOTHING for my skin tone.
The blush is divine......my favorite of the items I've purchased thus far.
Caractere is beautiful and will be perfect for fall - I could even get away with wearing it in the summer, but I'll probably save it ;).
The quad: I can get the light pink to show up on my hand but I'm not sure about the texture - it's smooth but maybe a bit chalky. The other light shade - the gold-ish color, shows up as well, and has a pretty gleam to it but isn't anything special. The taupe on the other hand....I really, really like. And the black is nice and pigmented. I actually think I'm going to keep it, and work Complice into the mix to see if that offers a new option. I will wear these tomorrow and see if I change my tune.
I'm awaiting Caprice now, and I want to check out Furtif based on what all of you have said........I'll probably skip the silver liner.