I've had rouge noir for about two weeks now, and I love it!! The matte velvet lipstick that belongs with the holiday collection has a touch more purple in it. I prefer the finish on the rouge noir. I am extremely pale, with blonde hair, and blue eyes. I find darker sheer colors easier to wear than lighter brights. I am a huge fan of Chanel and have been reading all your posts for a long time, but was a little nervous to contribute. You all seem so nice and I do share the same passion for makeup! My collection, at this point in my life, has grown embarrassingly huge, but somehow I think all of you lovely ladies will understand!! :)