If you stop by a Target store, they have a display in the cosmetic section that has new Maybelline Color Tattoo shades. Behind those 4 new Limited Edition Tattoo shades are also 4 new Maybelline COLORED mascaras! A blue, purple, teal, and green! Under $5! I grabbed the purple one today and can't wait to try it! Just wanted to suggest a cheaper, drugstore colored mascara for you ladies to try. As much as I wanted to try a colored mascara, I didn't want to pay big money for a mascara I won't reach for as often as a black or brown everyday color. Now I also have a Benefit lipgloss/mascara combo called Prrrowl. It has the coolest iridescent pink lipgloss that is gorgeous as a layering gloss for a fabulous night-out lip. And on the other end an AH-Mazing blue topcoat mascara! Very nice combo!! Just a little pricey for me to repurchase often as it runs $28 (if I remember correctly).
I actually bought that last week in the blue color! It's not very bright but I like it a lot because in the sunlight/bright light my eyelashes are noticeably blue tinted and for five bucks that's enough for me! If you want the runway look you probably won't like it but for a toned down version it is actually pretty good. The formula is a little finicky, I had to brush it through with a clean spoolie to get it to look good but in the end I was quite satisfied.