I get a kick out of how polarizing these products are. Very love or hate material....reminds me of the Big Bounces. I'm glad MAC is willing to put some off-the-wall products out there and let the customer decide yea or nay.
...and as usual, I'll just shill for those applicators (broken record, right?)...they really take the pain right out of these.
i was just thinking this today when i was removing my eye makeup (deeply dashing)...i have to admit i had a bit of trouble completely removing the glitter from my eyes. but when i wear these (over genuine treasure paint pot), the staying power is really good, and they wear so well -- it just looks like glistening skin!
not everyone is gonna love 'em, but in a way it's nice that mac (and other companies) put out new products frequently because it definitely keeps things interesting. i think the fact that they are also making these permanent is meaningful. they must have been a hit for a sufficient number of people!