just wanted to add my raves to this thread...i bought the plum perfect TLC (in the pot) the day it came out, aages ago, and have used it pretty much non-stop ever since. i LOVE it so much it never leaves my purse. people have bought it after seeing it on me! i find it good at moisturizing too. i bought one of the stick ones but returned it the next day because it was awful. no colour payoff, not that good at moisturizing, and after just 2 uses it started to bend to one side in the tube. also, i didn't like the packaging. since then i own and love aquamelon. i still haven't used my luellas, and i don't really like baumy bronze as much as i thought. anyway, GET one! the original tinted ones in the pot have good colour payoff, even for pigmented lips. the LE ones from the summer were more sheer, but shimmery. and the ones in the sticks were awful! i recently got the clear lip conditioner in the pot but haven't tried it yet.