Lipstick:
3N
Birds of a Feather
Blue Eve
California Dreamin'
Dense
Dream Vacation
Ever Hip (original)
Love, Henri
Plastique (mini lipstick)
Port Red
Screenqueen
Smoove
Squirt lipglass
I also have a bunch of the more recent rare items like the Apfel lipsticks, CYY and Moxie repromotes, and Heroine.
MSF:
Pleasureflush
Lightscapade (original)
Stereo Rose (original)
Metal Rock (sample of a broken one in a jar)
Blush:
Afterdusk
Cute
Emote
Stray Rose
Screwtop Eyeshadows:
Agean Green (my precioussssss)
Apollo
Atlas
Butterscotch
Celery
Century (got this for $15 in a sale a few months ago and practically screamed)
Clone
Cucumber
Fiction
Forest
Frigid
Fringe
Greystone
Haze
Hemp
Island Coral
Issue
Limit
Lola
Lyric
Mango
Marz
Melody
Ochre
Paisley
Phase
Pink Ice
Plexi
Riot
Robin
Santa Fe
Scheme
Shag
Slate
Solar
Stomp
Suede
Sunset
Surreal
Theme
Zone
My screwtop eyeshadows are my pride and joy. I consider those to be some of the most rare MAC items I own. As you can see, I am very serious about collecting them, haha. There are lots of other ones I am searching for, but so many are so old, they are next to impossible to find. I won't give up, though! There is just something about the hunt that is so thrilling. And I love having those pieces of MAC history, especially since powder products tend to last forever. Most of the colors are really so unique, too. I love pre-Lauder MAC, there was so much more of a true artistic feel to the brand.
Rare depotted/pro shadows:
Agate
Almond Icing
Amethyst
Anti-Establishment
Aria
Bagatelle
Bark
Blu-Noir
Brill
Clue
De Menthe
Dream
Earthly Delight
Elite
Eyepopping
Fake
Femme Noir
Firespot
Flirty Number
French Grey
Frill
Goldbit (Tantress)
Guacamole
Green Gamin
Gris
Hard To Please
Intoxicate
Lazy Green
Loungewear
Lustreleaf
Mancatcher
Meadow
Metamorph
Mothbrown and Moth Brown
Nighttrain
Oceanique
Olive Groove
Parisienne
Parrot
Parsley Sage
Pickle
Pleasurepurr
Plum
Putty
Rye
Saturnal
Say, Yeah
Scarab
Sea Myth
Signed, Sealed
Silly Goose
Sleepy
Smoke & Diamonds
Sorcery
Springtime Skipper
Sprout
Steep
Stroke of Midnight
Swan Lake
Twillery
Velvet Moss
Venus
Waternymph
Wondergrass
Large Eyeshadows:
Cantaloupe (screwtop)
Frappe
Iris Print
Overtint Green
Slick CCB
Tres Teal MES
Whim MES
Paint:
Stringalong Paint Pot
Brushes:
#143 pencil brush
#5 shader brush
#162 angled contour brush
#272 angled shader (my all-time favorite!!!)
I also have a brow/lash brush from when MAC was founded. It doesn't have a number, it just says "MAKE-UP ART BROW/LASH USA" on it. And I have a super old lip brush that has no lettering/numbering at all... it is definitely authentic, though. I have no idea how old it is, but it is OLD. And still performs like no time has passed at all!
Palettes/Quads:
Flowering Quad
Nordstrom Exclusive Eyes x 11... this palette is really cool, it contains Vex, Night Owl, and Perverted Pearl eyeshadows. I don't think I've ever seen another one for sale. I grabbed it for pretty cheap in a blogsale several years ago and thought I was dreaming. It has the original 213SE brush and Smolder liner, too.
Perverted Pearl Quad... I once had 2 of these--ridiculous!
Smoking Eyes Quad
Tease Me... Quad
Temperley palette
Pigments:
All-Girl
Auburn
Badlands (Rodarte)
Blue (original)
Brass
Bronze
Chartreuse
Coco x2 (my HG!)
Coco Beach
Copper
Deckchair
Dusty Coral
Forest Green
Gold (frost)
Gold Dusk
Green (frost)
Silver (frost)
Lustdust (glitter)
Maroon
Mustard
Orange (matte)
Pink (matte)
Purple (matte)
Royal Blue
Soft Washed
Subtle
Sunnydaze
All of the original pigment and glitter petites including Rose Gold and Blue/Brown, which were major PITAs to find!
Postcards:
5 Sins of Lipglass complete set
Cream Color (1996. One of my very favorite cards)
Danse (full body version)
Femme Noir (black and white version)
High Tea double-sided poster
MAC Pops Up! (from a 2010 event in Montreal)
Pure (Kool Kat version)
Rococo (gold overlay version)
Viva Glam (first ever VG card, '96)
Zoom Lash
I also have Haze nail lacquer. Apparently there were 2 versions of this polish--a duochrome blue/purple (blurple?) that I think was part of the permanent line and a different version that came out with Dolled Up, I believe. It is a seafoam green with pink/lavender duochrome shimmer. I have that one.
Also, I've always wondered--is Smoked Mauve pigment real or just a MAC legend?! I've heard that it was given out to MAC employees, but I have never been able to confirm its existence. Never seen a picture or knew of anyone who had it. There isn't even any info on Google.. like, AT ALL. Does anyone know for sure?
Edited by EUSHANNASIA - 9/23/12 at 9:19pm