NC 45 is the craziest shade

honeybrown1976

New member
I am so glad this forum and topic is here. I'm a NC42 and I've seen countless women of color use this shade (NC42) when it's clearly not for them. It makes them look ashy and downright bad. Stop the drama, embrace your true, not desired (what?) shade, and buy the right foundation color. In other words, knock it off. If you are a NC45 or darker (truly), stop wearing NC42. Love you! I do!
 

sweetie

Well-known member
So do you all think that NC 45 in fix fluid is the closest thing to C7 fix powder? Tried NC50 fluid-too dark and NW43-just ugly on me.
 

AppleDiva

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by blazeno.8
I have to say though... I think the default here for MAs is NW45.


OOoh yes. When I started with MAC foundations, I was given NW45 as a match...I looked so orange, it was ridiculous. It took me years to realize that I was NC44/NW43/NC50 combo.
 

MACaholic76

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by honeybrown1976
I am so glad this forum and topic is here. I'm a NC42 and I've seen countless women of color use this shade (NC42) when it's clearly not for them. It makes them look ashy and downright bad. Stop the drama, embrace your true, not desired (what?) shade, and buy the right foundation color. In other words, knock it off. If you are a NC45 or darker (truly), stop wearing NC42. Love you! I do!

You took the word out of my mouth! I love you for saying this! Amen!
 

MACaholic76

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by sweetie
So do you all think that NC 45 in fix fluid is the closest thing to C7 fix powder? Tried NC50 fluid-too dark and NW43-just ugly on me.

Honestly NC45 in Studio Fix Fluid is just sooo wrong. That shade matches no true NC45 in any way shape or form in my humble opinion.
 

dominichulinda

Well-known member
For anyone that close to my skin shade I got matched to the new Bobbi Brown Skin Foundation in "honey"... the corrector in Peach and the concealer in "honey" as well.

thanks to karla for the swatches:

bbskinfoundation2medium.jpg
 

dominichulinda

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by miss_primer
I was matched to NC45 in Studio Tech about 2 weeks ago. The foundation was to dark for me. Every time I applied it, i thought i must be too heavy handed with it. I thought i was caking it on..lol. When my mom saw me with it on she said thats way to dark for me. She took me outside with a mirror to prove me wrong because i denied it. I had to wipe off one side for her and leave the other side on. She was right. It was too dark.


one of my MA's matched me to the NC 43 in Studio Tech try that.
 

dominichulinda

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by elektra513
I agree, there is a big problem with NC45--each foundation formula makes the color different, like select spf versus studio fix versus studio fix fluid, etc. Plus you have to factor in how much makeup you are applying to your face (a dime-sized amount versus a quarter size) and how it's being applied.

All that to say, I gave up on Mac and moved on to Prescriptives.



So, right about that!! Each formula = a different shade lol (shakes fist to MAC lol).

I wear a different # in all there foundations lol, plus all gives a different coverage...so that maybe the problem :/
 

yummy411

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by F.A.B.
I was reading my Essence last night and when I saw that I thought it had to be typo. There is no way Serena is NC45. I'm wear a mix of NC45 and NC50 in Studio Fix Fluid. It also bothers me that I see some women with deeper skin tones than myself and they wear NC45. I do fault the MA but sometimes I wonder if some WOC have a problem embracing their dark skintone.

this is a great topic and there are many things to take into acct like other members have said. we change colors throughout the year, all of MAC shades don't run the same color.. similar but i'm not the same in studio fix fluid that I am in satin finish, etc. while in serena's case that may be a typo, sometimes it's no telling what artists use on shoots... rihanna's artist keeps her BRIGHT for the contouring etc, but either way nc45 is the default around these part hahaa!
 

dominichulinda

Well-known member
anyone tried "Hello Flawless!" SPF 15 by benefit??

What it does:
Benefit "Hello Flawless!" SPF 15 is a blendable powder foundation with SPF 15 that goes on beautifully sheer and layers easily for customized coverage.

Color info on some:

"All The World's My Stage" Beige
(sunny beige/ for medium beige complexions))
Item # 1153402

"It's About Me, Me, Me!" Toffee
(toasted toffee/ for medium deep mocha complexions)
Item # 1153428



"Why Walk When You Can Strut?" Hazelnut
(rich hazelnut/ for deep mocha complexions)
Item # 1153444
 

MAHALO

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by makeuplover7239
You should try Medium Deep if Dark is too dark and orangey for you. It is slightly browner than Medium Dark.

tong.gif


I tested Medium Dark at a CCO last week. It wasn't right for me. Unfortunately, they didn't have Medium Deep. I'll keep an eye out for it. Thanks again for the tip.
 

MAHALO

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by dominichulinda
For anyone that close to my skin shade I got matched to the new Bobbi Brown Skin Foundation in "honey"... the corrector in Peach and the concealer in "honey" as well.

thanks to karla for the swatches:

bbskinfoundation2medium.jpg


Thank you for the swatches. I purchased WARM ALMOND in the BB Moisture foundation last week at a CCO. In the store it looked fine but now I can see it's a little to rich for my skintone. I may need GOLDEN or perhaps a mix of GOLDEN and WARM ALMOND. I'm NC45 winter/NW43 summer MAC SPF or Mineralized Satin Finish only. What do you suggest?
 

elongreach

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by makeuplover7239
I think you should try Medium Deep. It's one shade lighter than Dark and it is so different compared to Dark MSF! I used to look orangey with Dark and I switched to Medium Deep and it works out perfectly!

Ok, please someone help me out. I went to MAC this Friday and as usual was talking about foundations and powders. I should have talked about it with the MA at the freestanding store who would have probably understand my issues a little more.

However, on my way out I stopped at Nordstrom and was looking around again. She thought maybe since NC45 was oxidizing badly on me maybe I should change Powders (I currently use Medium Deep). Because she really didn't think I was NC42. Then she did this compare and contrast with NC42 on one side and NC44 on the other side (I hate that).

Honestly I can never tell the difference with the lights in Nordies. So I bought the Medium Dark Powder thinking that maybe I could use that powder on my off days when I don't feel like doing myself all the way up because Medium Deep oxidizes on me as well when I wear it alone.

But point of this long rant is what is the chain of Skinfinishes? Because from what this MA told me is that M Dark is lighter than Deep. Was she wrong? Because I can go back to Nordies on Monday and return that sucker. I shouldn't have bought it in the first place. But I have this awful habit of buying things just because I've taken time from the MA for nothing.
 

dominichulinda

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by MAHALO
Thank you for the swatches. I purchased WARM ALMOND in the BB Moisture foundation last week at a CCO. In the store it looked fine but now I can see it's a little to rich for my skintone. I may need GOLDEN or perhaps a mix of GOLDEN and WARM ALMOND. I'm NC45 winter/NW43 summer MAC SPF or Mineralized Satin Finish only. What do you suggest?

bbn.jpg

I got sample packs from nordies. One pack allow 3 uses when using the #187 brush. You should asked the nordies for two colors. I asked for "honey and golden"..I'm saving the "golden" to mix w/ the "honey" to see how it will do for the summer.

next time your at nordies get a samples of "Warm almond" and "golden"
smiles.gif
 

MACaholic76

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by elongreach
Ok, please someone help me out. I went to MAC this Friday and as usual was talking about foundations and powders. I should have talked about it with the MA at the freestanding store who would have probably understand my issues a little more.

However, on my way out I stopped at Nordstrom and was looking around again. She thought maybe since NC45 was oxidizing badly on me maybe I should change Powders (I currently use Medium Deep). Because she really didn't think I was NC42. Then she did this compare and contrast with NC42 on one side and NC44 on the other side (I hate that).

Honestly I can never tell the difference with the lights in Nordies. So I bought the Medium Dark Powder thinking that maybe I could use that powder on my off days when I don't feel like doing myself all the way up because Medium Deep oxidizes on me as well when I wear it alone.

But point of this long rant is what is the chain of Skinfinishes? Because from what this MA told me is that M Dark is lighter than Deep. Was she wrong? Because I can go back to Nordies on Monday and return that sucker. I shouldn't have bought it in the first place. But I have this awful habit of buying things just because I've taken time from the MA for nothing.


I know everyone seems to really love these skinfinishes powders but to me, they all oxidize badly, especially the darker ones. I'm wondering if you could just get the regular pressed powder and try that instead of the skinfinish to see how it goes?
th_dunno.gif
 

elongreach

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by MACaholic76
I know everyone seems to really love these skinfinishes powders but to me, they all oxidize badly, especially the darker ones. I'm wondering if you could just get the regular pressed powder and try that instead of the skinfinish to see how it goes?
th_dunno.gif


Hmm, maybe I'll return what I bought for regular pressed powder, they're probably about the same price. Is anyone else having a problem with mac's website or is it just me?
 

Jade09

Active member
The only skinfinish I had a problem with was Dark, I agree that it just doesn't oxidize well at all. After I was re-matched with NC42 satinfinish, I got Medium Dark and sometimes I use Medium Deep with it and after many hours I don't look ridiculously orange, which happened several times with NC44 & Dark skinfinish combo.
 

uabiola

Active member
There is no way that Serena in NC anything! She has warm undertones, from what I can see. Also, she is darker than me, and Im a NC 50. Now I really think Im a NC 47, but that doesnt exist to my knowledge. I say that because NC45 is a little light, and NC 50 is a little dark. But Id rather have it be a little dark than look like Casper or pale face..ugh!..I hate that ashy Larry look, lmao!

mac_addict.gif
 

ms. kendra

Well-known member
This is interesting.
I just got matched yesterday for the first time ( I don't usually wear foundation). I'm NC45! I would have thought I'd be a shade lighter. I'd compare my complexion to that of Sanaa Lathan. The MUA matched me perfectly to NC45, with Medium Deep MSF, and it's perfect!
I had goggled pics of people who are this same shade and it's amazing to see the variations.
 

Latest posts

Top