your most hated mac e/s?

MacAddict09

Active member

• Apr 4, 2009

• #41

Mythology, it was my first Mac eyeshadow.

 

thespry

Active member

• Apr 4, 2009

• #42

Quote:

Originally Posted by MacAddict09 Mythology, it was my first Mac eyeshadow.

Oh no! I was just about to buy Mythology... why do you hate it?

 

MacAddict09

Active member

• Apr 4, 2009

• #43

I couldnt make it work on me. It looked like I had a rash. Plus the color pay off was pretty poor.

 

geeko

Well-known member

• Apr 4, 2009

• #44

Sorry i know many girls love club

But i hate IT. THE greyish brown duochrome makes me look bruised. BOO!

 

VioletB

Well-known member

• Apr 4, 2009

• #45

Filament, forgery, idol eyes, and any other lustres for that matter. Since hate is such a strong word, they do look pretty over CCB's but who wants to wear ccb on their eyes all the time?? I heart newly minted. Looks SO pretty with aquavert.

 

shootout

Well-known member

• Apr 4, 2009

• #46

Newly minted for sure!
I bring it out like once a month hoping that it ages well or something I guess.
But no, it looks like shit, every single time.
Do I return it? No.
Because someday, I will NEED an e/s that color.
I swear.

 

GirlyDork

Well-known member

• Apr 4, 2009

• #47

I absolutely HATE Passionate!!! No wonder it's called Passionate, because I HATE IT WITH A PASSION!!! Its payoff is pathetic and impossible to even layer, even when I use a good base and the 239 brush. It makes my eyes look bloodshot and irritated. My eyes actually do get a bit irritated from trying to pack on the color so much. Don't get me wrong, the color is pretty in the container, but it just doesn't work as an eye shadow, if ANYTHING.

Parfait Amour doesn't show up enough, either.

Stars N' Rockets has really lame payoff for such a beautiful color. I'm so glad MAC made Pink Pearl pigment. I need to get some of that stuff...

I really dislike all Lustre and Velvet finish eye shadows by MAC. A lot of the Mattes suck, too. However, not all of the Matte2s are terrible. (I love Post Haste, but I need to find out how to wear it...)

 

coachkitten

Well-known member

• Apr 4, 2009

• #48

An eye shadow that I dislike is plum pro shadow. I have said it many times before but I would get more color for rubbing purple chalk on my lids.

 

USCgirlie

Well-known member

• Apr 5, 2009

• #49

Satin Taupe and Mulch both looked horrible on my NC35 skin, dark brown eyes. They made my eye area look dirty, as well as tired

. Too bad because I know that these are two very popular and well-loved colors...

 

Tsunami Rose

Well-known member

• Apr 5, 2009

• #50

I really hate Newlyminted. EWxGAZILLION. I also dislike Pen N Pink, it has no pigmentation what so ever. I kind of dislike Aquadisiac as well. I hardly use it.

 

moopoint

Well-known member

• Apr 5, 2009

• #51

I exponentionally hate Mythology. Worst buy ever.
I dislike Da Bling, too "bubblegum" pink for my taste. And poor color payoff.
I dislike Creme D' Violet. Hard to blend IMO.

It's sad sbout other's hate for Nocturnelle and Texture. I <3 them.

 

Mizz.Coppertone

Well-known member

• Apr 5, 2009

• #52

probaly creme de violet. i need to a force an fotd out with that evil shadow lol. i think about ways to get it to look good all the time but i never try them because i know it will be a pain to wipe off because its such a bright purple. it's like bruise purple lol.

honey lust is beautiful but the freaking sparkles fall out like crazy.

 

claralikesguts

Well-known member

• Apr 5, 2009

• #53

i'm beginning to hate paradisco

such a shame because i LOVE the color, but it's practically invisible unless i use 9238493 layers over a really sticky base. and it crusts like craaaaazy

 

Prototype83

Well-known member

• Apr 8, 2009

• #54

I hate Kelly e/s (Pro). I can't get it to work for me no matter what I try! Maybe it's the texture. Plus on me, it looks very alot like Newly Minted (which I adore!).

Kick rocks Kelly e/s......KICK ROCKS!!!! (runs away crying)


lol....but seriously, can't stand it!

P.S. My most hated e/s used to be Warm Chill, but now I use it w/ a damp brush over Greenstroke p/p. LOVE!

 

NeonKitty

Well-known member

• Apr 8, 2009

• #55

I personally hate Aquavert, yuck, so pastey on me, which is sad because it is actually a pretty colour.

Any lustre e/s, will not even consider buying, so chalky and gritty, blech!

I really like some of the hated shadows here: Passionate <3 outer half of lid with chrome yellow inner half, blend and <3
Club works for me too, I love it to darken the outer V and crease when wearing neutrals and browns (as opposed to using carbon). I think it would wear well with humid, but have yet to try this to know for sure

 

lindas1983

Well-known member

• Apr 8, 2009

• #56

Filament e/s, glitter chunkys galour need I say more, yuk!!!

 

contrabassoon

Well-known member

• Apr 8, 2009

• #57

Newly Minted suck balls. Pen N' Pink is pretty bad as well, but I don't hate it as much as I have Newly Minted.

 

G

GlamQueen21

Well-known member

• Apr 8, 2009

• #58

I did a look using Passionate e/s and I had to do like 3 or 4 layers of it and the color payoff was horrible!! I don't know why I bought it since I've been wanting that e/s for quite awhile. I also dislike Dear Cupcake! Usually I don't have a problem with Satin e/s but this one had to be the worst! Poor, poor color payoff!

 

chaffsters33

Well-known member

• Apr 8, 2009

• #59

HONEY LUST!!! I'll see myself in a mirror and be like "Oh hello random unwelcome speck of glitter on my face, how did you get there? Oh right I had a brain malfunction and bought friggin honeylust!"

French Cuff: barely pigmented, crumply, does that weird crust over thing..I just have no desire to put that on my face.

Felt Blue: What is this eyeshadows purpose for life?!?!?!!?

Floral Fantasy: I only bought it because it was at a CCO

 

silencemylips

Well-known member

• Apr 8, 2009

• #60

trax. just can't use it & can't get rid of it either!