One of my favorite "pink eyes" is:
Yogurt - lid blended up past crease
Girlie - Crease
Melton Mauve - Depth on outer 3/4 of eye
Those colors have the benefit of not being frosty and it's extremely feminine and polished. Girlie is the only shadow out of the 3 with any frost in it (and it's very little), it can be easily dropped out of the eye if you prefer no shimmer.