Honeylove, Blankety or Innocence Beware?

rachelizabethx

New member
I'm torn between Honeylove, Blankety and Innocence Beware. From what I can see they're extremely similar. Can anyone with these shades list pros & cons to help me make my decision? And also, if anyone can do a side by side (by side) comparison swatch that'd be a huge help!!
 

Naynadine

Veteran Moderator
Staff member
I'm torn between Honeylove, Blankety and Innocence Beware. From what I can see they're extremely similar. Can anyone with these shades list pros & cons to help me make my decision? And also, if anyone can do a side by side (by side) comparison swatch that'd be a huge help!!
I can only compare Blankety and Innocence Beware and in my opinion they're not very similar. Blankety is darker and more pigmented whereas IB is sheerer and goes on a little streaky (and it was also limited edition, so I don't know if you could still find it somewhere). So I would recommend Blankety, it has a nicer formula overall, and looking at your profile pic I think it would look great on you. :)
 

Jennifae

Specktra Bestie
Blankety seems pinker than Honeylove. Innocence, Beware! looks pinker than Blankety. It was limited edition, and I personally didn't like the texture, so I would recommend either Blankety or Honeylove.

ETA: If you want a matte finish, go for Honeylove. If you want a creamier finish with more shine, go for Blankety.
 

rachelizabethx

New member
Blankety seems pinker than Honeylove. Innocence, Beware! looks pinker than Blankety. It was limited edition, and I personally didn't like the texture, so I would recommend either Blankety or Honeylove.

ETA: If you want a matte finish, go for Honeylove. If you want a creamier finish with more shine, go for Blankety.
Thanks! I only have about 12 MAC lipsticks at the moment and I haven't really found an ideal finish yet. I know I don't like lustre or frost too much though. I went for Honeylove in the end but I still want to try Blankety
 

Thia Winter

Member
I have all three.

I LOVE Blankety, it's my HG, or at least it was until I developed a gluten sensitivity. There's gluten in the Amplified Creams. Now Honeylove is my HG, or one of them. Color wise blankety is just a tad pinker than honeylove but it's not much. As for Innocence, Beware, There's gluten in the Cremesheens too. Colorwise it's lighter and pinker than blankety. My favorite is Blankety for the color of the three.
 

missindependent

New member
Can anyone help me how to wear Honeylove? I just got it but didn't like it when I got home. I am very fair, NW15 or even more pale...
 

Latest posts

Top