I did the same thing and the color payoff was a dud.
So I ended up exchanging it for another e/s. I guess it depends on your skin tone OR what base you use under it.
Someone suggested to use Pharaoh paint pot from the McQueen collection and then use newly minted over it. I believe the swatch is in the swatch forum. And the color does pay off over it so you might want to give that a try. =)