most overrated - Real Doll... seriously, how many baby bubble gum pink lustres does MAC make? More than any of us can poke a bloody stick at, it isnt unique nor undupeable and MAC will never stop making those sorts of pinks... Miss Ross comes to mind, California Dreamin, Fun Fun... bleh.... take your pick, they all fit the description.
Most underrated - Strawbaby. This colour should be perm. There just arent that many unscary reds available and this one is super tame for all the girlies who love the idea of wearing red but arent ready to jump into the deep end with Russian Red yet
The most overrated MAC l/s, IMO, is Hug Me. It is so not wearable for this NC 15/20ish, dark hair & eyed girl. I don't know if it's my pigmented lips or what, but this has always, always looked awful on me!
I know it's different for everyone, but my underrated fave is Lovelorn. It's a great pink that I hardly hear anything about!
I don't know about overrated. I know I've got caught up in the hype, and bought a few that didn't suit me. I know I was able to trade that weird salmon colour from the Raquel cover story for some good haulage.
Underrated: Embraceable. Oh how deeply I love that shade, and I'm nearly finished my second (and only) tube.