MAC Give me Liberty of London Discussion

purrtykitty

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by Civies
If my life depended on it I still couldn't get the Perfect Cheek to show up on me but it's so pretty swatched ..
ssad.gif


It truly was the Perfect Cheek on me. I looked everywhere and reorganized all my stuff to no avail.
ssad.gif
Since it's no longer available, I'm going to cross my fingers that I can find it at the CCO I'm visiting in two weeks.
 

Modmom

Well-known member
Re: Is STRKE A POSE a dupe for....

I would say so. If you look in the swatch thread for GMLOL, someone did a great comparison picture.
 

tropical_smiles

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by xoleaxo
wow, i'm LOVING prim & proper. I'm soo glad I decided to get it! I was on the fence because I heard it was pretty similar to Eversun & Fun & Games.. but it's totally different. It looks great on medium-tan skin-- I'm NC35. It's a beautiful natural flush of color; not too tan/brown like Eversun & Fun & Games.

Blooming Lovely is really pretty & unique in my collection. It's pretty purpley (lol) on my lips but looks to be a great night color. I haven't tried pairing it with any glosses yet since I rarely wear them.

I got the medium bag & I agree it feels cheap! For $30 I expect at least some lining on that sucker! The material is very thin & flimsy like someone previously mentioned.

Overall, enjoying my small haul & am IN LOVE with the packaging!!


Really I'm still on the fence with prim and proper...I have eversun and fun and games...do you have a comparison swatch that you could show me?
 

misha5150

Well-known member
So after reading the many rave reviews and lemming on buying Shell Pearl b/p I finally caved in and ran to Macy's to buy it this morning!!
tong.gif
I wanted to get Petals' & Peacock l/s too but they were already sold out of it.
thmbdn.gif
I guess I'll just have to order it online. *sigh* I'm NC45 and Shell Pearl looks great on me. It's soooo smooth and it does give a glow from within look. It leans more champange/peach on me so blending is the key to not have that ashy look. I swatched it against By Candlelight and BC is much more pink and the glitter is much more noticeable. I'm glad I have both and the white compact is just too cute!! Oh and Shell Pearl also works great for a subtle browbone highlighter!! HTH!
 

Miss QQ

Well-known member
^^ I hope you can get your hands on Shell Pearl and P&P.

Quote:
Originally Posted by LMD84
who am i kidding? i'm not going to be able to skip shell pearl powder at all am i!?
tong.gif


thmbup.gif



Quote:
Originally Posted by capmorlovesmac
You can always skip something from a later collection.
yes.gif

This gorgeous BP plus the pretty packaging are worth to skip some other items.
smiles.gif


iagree.gif


So guess what? My list has just expanded to include Summer Rose. I want Shell Pearl and SR!
yes.gif



Quote:
Originally Posted by Susanne
I can't wait to wear Birds & Berries and Bough Grey together with Blue India on my nails
th_DANCE.gif

I just bought the perfect new shirt for these colours
winks.gif


Can't wait for your FOTD with the matching shirt!
winkiss.gif


Quote:
Originally Posted by elegant-one
I swatched a few things -

Creme Anglaise is a rose/red/berry

English Accents is an Orchid Pink - which is a pinky lavender violet color. Its also somewhere in between Negligee lg & Frozen Dream lg

I love that it is more opaque! Its beautiful on.


drools.gif
drools.gif
I'm predicting the next item to hop into my list will be EA.
winks.gif
 

DILLIGAF

Well-known member
Re: Is STRKE A POSE a dupe for....

So did I but now I keep wanting to go back and reswatch it. According to the pic that I saw its almost an exact dupe.
 

Mygreatlove

Well-known member
So my mom came with me shopping yesterday so I could see the collection in person since hubby doesn't see the need to drive so far for makeup
thmbdn.gif
I already have Shell Pearl and Prim & Proper coming in the mail Tuesday, and I went in definitely wanting Blue India. The store was sooo busy but everything was still in stock. This was at Glendale Galleria in CA. Anyways, I almost got it, but I never actually paid attention to how small the polishes are! So, I talked myself out of it since it's not really my color and I mainly wanted it because of the hype. But I did walk away with Dame's Desire and Bough Grey. So not too bad for this collection... only 4 things
choochoo.gif
Ha.
 

Gonzajuju

Well-known member
I'm really loving Bough Grey e/s. It's giving my everyday neutrals a kick! I wore it yesterday with birds& berries in the outer V. Also, I'm sooo so happy I went back to buy shell pearl! It even looks good as an eye highlight!
 

only1angel

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by Swirlgirl
LOVE your Youtube channel! Great LOL swatches and I can't wait to see what you come up with for a look from the collection
th_wiggle2.gif

What are your thoughts on everything?? I hope you like Peachstock as much as I do...


Thanks
th_hug.gif



I got my goodies yesterday and I really wasn't expecting to get much from this collection, but I ended up coming home with more than half of it! I do have to say, though, that I ended up going home and playing with my goodies, and there are a few that I didn't like AT ALL!
nope.gif
I think this will be the first collection that I'm returning a ton of stuff from. The most I've ever returned from a collection was one, if anything....2 tops!

Here's what I got:

All 4 lippies (I've never tried these formulas before so I didn't know what I was expecting)
Blooming Lovely- this shows up on me extremely purple, but like a dead corpse like purple
th_confused_new.gif
. I'm going to try it with In Synch and a pink lipglass and maybe that will bring the pink out a bit. If not, this is going back! I'm not really a fan of having to make the extra effort to make a lippie work, but we'll see.
Ever Hip- swatched on my hand this color looked like a nice sheer coral color. I figured I'd love this since I really love Fresh Salmon (PERFECT everyday coral color BTW). But Ever Hip looks orange on me
angry.gif
. This one's a no no!
nope.gif

Petals & Peacocks- I wasn't going to get this but my MA talked me into it. This was just way over the top on me! I saw some FOTDs with this that looked gorgeous! It looked like a nice baby pink on some! But on me it is just too bright, and has more of a violet tone to it. Both are out of my element, but if I had to choose between this or Show Orchid, I'd go with Show Orchid. These two aren't similar on me at all by the way.
Peachstock- From the beginning of this collection, this was the one lippie I thought for sure I wasn't going to get. But for some reason I bought it b/c of all the hype (shocker there huh lol
tong.gif
) and OMG I LOVE THIS LIPPIE!!!!! And Swirlgirl- YES, I DO like it as much as you do!!!!!!
cutey.gif
Wow, this lippie is incredible to create a nude lip! I can't explain what's so great about this lippie, but you just have to try it lol. This gives you the perfect nude lips without having to apply lip erase- AND this doesn't give you the nude look that makes your lips seem like you have concealer on them. I don't have anything like this in my collection! This is definitely a keeper!
Dame's Desire- a nice purple color! It reminds me of a more purple version of stars n rockets! Can't wait to use this and play with different looks!
Bough Grey- doesn't come across as being super pigmented when swatched, but if you pack it onto your brush, you get a ton of pigmentation. I'm still going to play around with this one. I love greys, but this one isn't wowing me just yet. But it does seem, however, like it would be great to use in smokey eye looks!
Prim & Proper-
drools.gif
Need I say more???
greengrin.gif
lol.gif
Gives your cheeks a nice natural flush of color. This is COMPLETELY different from Eversun & Fun n Games. Fun n Games gives you that super light/just barely there tone to your cheeks. I usually wear FnG when I have no makeup on just to give me a natural glow since it's super light. Eversun gives you that flush of color that makes you look like you just got out of the sun. Prim & Proper is pure love!!!!!
love.gif
It met all my expectations!!!! This blush is AMAZING with.......Shell Pearl!!!!!
Shell Pearl- I was so AGAINST getting this b/c I have so many MSFs that are hardly even touched, and why would I need another highlight shade??? But of course, you guys were going crazy about it and it's sold out everywhere so basically that's why I got it
th_LMAO.gif
When I tried this on alone, it actually has enough of a light peachy tint for me to wear alone as a natural looking, glowy blush. But with Prim & Proper it's gorgeous and seriously drool worthy
th_LMAO.gif
. I actually like Prim & Proper better with Shell Pearl! It really changes the tone a bit. Is it bad of me for wanting to keep Shell Pearl only to use it with Prim & Proper??? lol
Blue India- This color didn't wow me but I bought it anyway thinking I'd like it. I don't usually wear darker shades, with the exception of black, so this was something different for me. Hubby liked it though! But guess what? I wore it yesterday, and now looking at my nails as I'm typing this, and.....it's already started to chip
angry.gif
angry.gif
This is my first MAC polish and I am not happy about the chipping part!!!! I'm returning this!!!


It's 12am but I feel like playing with my makeup and not going to sleep just yet lol. I think I'm going to see what looks I can come up with from this collection. Maybe I could make the lippies work?........
th_dunno.gif
 

Goat Goat Etc.

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by MACPixie
Shontay - have you tried MAC Paints? They are my HG bases! They are easy to blend but stay put once they're dry! I ALWAYS have problems with paint pots creasing but never with paints! I put a thin layer of TFSI everyday (I find it lasts about 12+hrs this way, without TFSI about 8hrs) and never have any creasing by the time I get home! Even through snow, rain, going to the gym etc. They are amazing! Sadly so many of the fun colours have been discontinued
ssad.gif


thmbup.gif
The paints are amazing! They need to bring back Architecture for us chocolate girls (or just me, whichever comes first)!
 

Gonzajuju

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by only1angel
Thanks
th_hug.gif



I got my goodies yesterday and I really wasn't expecting to get much from this collection, but I ended up coming home with more than half of it! I do have to say, though, that I ended up going home and playing with my goodies, and there are a few that I didn't like AT ALL!
nope.gif
I think this will be the first collection that I'm returning a ton of stuff from. The most I've ever returned from a collection was one, if anything....2 tops!

Here's what I got:

All 4 lippies (I've never tried these formulas before so I didn't know what I was expecting)
Blooming Lovely- this shows up on me extremely purple, but like a dead corpse like purple
th_confused_new.gif
. I'm going to try it with In Synch and a pink lipglass and maybe that will bring the pink out a bit. If not, this is going back! I'm not really a fan of having to make the extra effort to make a lippie work, but we'll see.
Ever Hip- swatched on my hand this color looked like a nice sheer coral color. I figured I'd love this since I really love Fresh Salmon (PERFECT everyday coral color BTW). But Ever Hip looks orange on me
angry.gif
. This one's a no no!
nope.gif

Petals & Peacocks- I wasn't going to get this but my MA talked me into it. This was just way over the top on me! I saw some FOTDs with this that looked gorgeous! It looked like a nice baby pink on some! But on me it is just too bright, and has more of a violet tone to it. Both are out of my element, but if I had to choose between this or Show Orchid, I'd go with Show Orchid. These two aren't similar on me at all by the way.
Peachstock- From the beginning of this collection, this was the one lippie I thought for sure I wasn't going to get. But for some reason I bought it b/c of all the hype (shocker there huh lol
tong.gif
) and OMG I LOVE THIS LIPPIE!!!!! And Swirlgirl- YES, I DO like it as much as you do!!!!!!
cutey.gif
Wow, this lippie is incredible to create a nude lip! I can't explain what's so great about this lippie, but you just have to try it lol. This gives you the perfect nude lips without having to apply lip erase- AND this doesn't give you the nude look that makes your lips seem like you have concealer on them. I don't have anything like this in my collection! This is definitely a keeper!
Dame's Desire- a nice purple color! It reminds me of a more purple version of stars n rockets! Can't wait to use this and play with different looks!
Bough Grey- doesn't come across as being super pigmented when swatched, but if you pack it onto your brush, you get a ton of pigmentation. I'm still going to play around with this one. I love greys, but this one isn't wowing me just yet. But it does seem, however, like it would be great to use in smokey eye looks!
Prim & Proper-
drools.gif
Need I say more???
greengrin.gif
lol.gif
Gives your cheeks a nice natural flush of color. This is COMPLETELY different from Eversun & Fun n Games. Fun n Games gives you that super light/just barely there tone to your cheeks. I usually wear FnG when I have no makeup on just to give me a natural glow since it's super light. Eversun gives you that flush of color that makes you look like you just got out of the sun. Prim & Proper is pure love!!!!!
love.gif
It met all my expectations!!!! This blush is AMAZING with.......Shell Pearl!!!!!
Shell Pearl- I was so AGAINST getting this b/c I have so many MSFs that are hardly even touched, and why would I need another highlight shade??? But of course, you guys were going crazy about it and it's sold out everywhere so basically that's why I got it
th_LMAO.gif
When I tried this on alone, it actually has enough of a light peachy tint for me to wear alone as a natural looking, glowy blush. But with Prim & Proper it's gorgeous and seriously drool worthy
th_LMAO.gif
. I actually like Prim & Proper better with Shell Pearl! It really changes the tone a bit. Is it bad of me for wanting to keep Shell Pearl only to use it with Prim & Proper??? lol
Blue India- This color didn't wow me but I bought it anyway thinking I'd like it. I don't usually wear darker shades, with the exception of black, so this was something different for me. Hubby liked it though! But guess what? I wore it yesterday, and now looking at my nails as I'm typing this, and.....it's already started to chip
angry.gif
angry.gif
This is my first MAC polish and I am not happy about the chipping part!!!! I'm returning this!!!


It's 12am but I feel like playing with my makeup and not going to sleep just yet lol. I think I'm going to see what looks I can come up with from this collection. Maybe I could make the lippies work?........
th_dunno.gif


I was wondering what you'd say about this collection since we're so similar in coloring, including hair (I've gotta update my avatar pic sometime so you can see what I mean). Blooming Lovely made me look dead and corpselike. English accents l/g made it look better on me but then again English accents can hold it's own. I think the reason EA l/g didn't make me look dead was because it had enough mauve in it.
Ever Hip turned orange on me. I'm surprised you liked peachstock l/s though. I didn't even swatch it since it looked like something that wouldnt work on me. Can you put up a pic of it on you? Also, I love your new youtube site!!! You mentioned on it that you're a skincare junkie, (me too) can you do a video on that?
 

omgitzstephanie

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by only1angel
Ever Hip- swatched on my hand this color looked like a nice sheer coral color. I figured I'd love this since I really love Fresh Salmon (PERFECT everyday coral color BTW). But Ever Hip looks orange on me
angry.gif
. This one's a no no!
nope.gif


Aw, I'm sad that you don't like Ever Hip! I agree with you that I don't like to make lippies work but if you pair it over In Synch, it looks really nice! Hopefully you'll like it
smiles.gif


And btw, I'm proud you didn't get Summer Rose BP!
th_LMAO.gif
Atleast one of us has some restraint ..
 

Goat Goat Etc.

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by shontay07108
I believe Knight Divine is definitely darker. Regardless, it's drool worthy, so you should check it out.
choochoo.gif


Knight vs. Knight Divine?
Is there a difference?
 

Goat Goat Etc.

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by MsWestchesterNY
That's what I'm doing. I applied one coat on my bottom lip, pressed my suckers together, did it again with the top lip. Then I applied that MUFE gloss #9 VERY lightly on the center of my lips

Okay you were very right!
yes.gif
I tossed my "give a-f*** what everybody else thinks" out the window and did the the dab and smoosh and topped my lips off with Lavender Wind l/g---for work! I had texture and black liner on my lid. Everything was very simple and sweet, I felt innocent and sexy! Thank you!
 

cocodivatime

Well-known member
I've totally learned my lesson. I rushed to buy Birds and Berries, without looking through my complete stash to make sure I didnt have a dupe.

So after getting it today I go to look at my Urban Decay Book of Shadows I and II just to make sure there was no dupe in there and what do I find in the BOS II?.....
JINX eye shadow!!
It looked almost exact to Birds and Berries
angry.gif


When I put them side by side Jinx appeared ever so lighter than B&B but darn close. But then when I put then on my eyes to try for myself..... it was a dead on dupe. I put one on each of my eyelids and both of them looked the SAME. BAH!!!!!!

From now on I must check my COMPLETE collection for dupes before running out. I've told myself this before but apparently I'm hard headed.
th_dunno.gif


The colors may come out different depending on your skin tones but on mine they are exact. Just a heads up to those who already have Urban Decay Jinx
 

kiss

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by cocodivatime
So after getting it today I go to look at my Urban Decay Book of Shadows I and II just to make sure there was no dupe in there and what do I find in the BOS II?.....
JINX eye shadow!!
It looked almost exact to Birds and Berries
angry.gif



That's odd. There are completely 2 different colors for me but perhaps we have different skintones.

Quote:
Originally Posted by only1angel


. Maybe I could make the lippies work?........
th_dunno.gif


You totally can! I love Blooming Lovely, I find it a very flattering muted mauvey color. Not purple or corpse like at all. I received alot of compliments on it.
 

cocodivatime

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by kiss
That's odd. There are completely 2 different colors for me but perhaps we have different skintones.




Yeah, thats why I was saying it may vary on different skintones. For me they are total dupes.
yes.gif
I'm an NC44/ BE Tan
 
Top