I second Russian Red l/g it's gorgeous!
I really like Ruby Woo l/s as it looks like a true red on me. However if you suit more corally reds maybe try Lady Danger l/s.
Thanks everyone. After making this thread I went on the MAC website and looked up what colors I think I might like and I liked russian red...and now that I read the suggestions...I'm def going to get it after work.
Ruffian Red lipstick if it is still in stock. If not, MAC Red. I would get the Russian Red gloss for layering. If you like more of a matte finish, Eden Rouge mattene. HTH