Satin Taupe, Brun, Mystery. (Actually, I find Brun and Mystery are pretty similar to each other, even though they look different in the pans. So you could pick one and skip the other, if you wanted.)
Omega is a great transition shade, as well for brows. Espresso is a darker brown, but lighter than Brun/Mystery. Shale is a nice, cool grey-purple-taupe-ish color.