Dilemma: UD Soot Liquid E/L Vs. MAC Liquidlast

[ShadowyLady]

I just bought Urban Decay's liquid eyeliner in Soot, but now that Liquidlast is out, I'm lusting after Point Black. Should I return Soot? I do like the depth of Soot; it has a slight silvery shimmer a la Phone Number eye kohl. Any opinions?

 

[pumpkincat210]

The liquidlast's are true to their name and stay on.. I saw Point Black and it is soooo black....the blackest liner i've seen. It stays slightly shiny, but not much at all. The quality of my Fuschia-ism is great, I've had it on all day, its still here and not irritating. I'd say go for it and they are permanent.