Is MAC rated r eyeshadow similar to overgrown?

[catemoody]

or is it different enough that i absoloutley need it?
thanks for your opinions

 

[minni4bebe]

I'm not sure if it is but its almost exactly the same as sharp from the tempting quad. The difference is the texture and I think Rated R has more sheen.

 

[yupitzTara]

I dont have overgrown, but i have Rated R, and i love it. the texture is so smooth and is a really pretty color. Here's a swatch from the swatches for "love that look" http://www.specktra.net/forum/f217/m...l-09-a-142894/

 

[MzzRach]

I agree that Rated R is very very close to Sharp from last year's Tempting quad.