This one is authentic
I had two of them myself, traded one, and of the one I kept i got rid of Brash (the coppery one) and Spiced Chocolate (the matte), I onyl kept Nanogold and Sweet Chestnut. Nanogold has a not so good texture to be honest, but the colour is amazing and well worth the effort. Brash has a gorgeous smooth texture (VP) but I didnt like the colour on me, pity was so very pretty!! Sweet Chestnut doesnt have such a good colour payoff really, but its quite pretty too, and Spiced Chocolate the matte, well... its a matte
LOLOL!!!