MAC Fluidline or Bobbi Brown Gel Liner?

[shadowaddict]

Just wondering which you guys like best. I have only used fluidline but it does seem to dry up easy in the jar. I have heard good things about BB gel liner. And BB does have some pretty colors especially "Black Mauve Shimmer Ink" and "Black Plum Ink" but I have only sen these online so I'm not sure how the color is in person. Any comments would be appreciated. Thanks

 

[lilMAClady]

Bobbi Brown definitely. It's creamy and long wearing.

 

[MzzRach]

I like both formulas a lot. The BB is definitely long wearing and comes in some great shades.

 

[sharkbytes]

the Black Mauve Shimmer is to die for, seriously. I love it so much!

 

[ginger9]

BB is super expensive in Canada, I didn't find it superior to MAC. I would just get it for the colors that BB offers. I got the graphite shimmer (I think that's what its call) its a really awesome color.

 

[Kiss and Makeup]

I've never tried BB, so I can't contribute there. If you're finding ANY of your gel eyeliners are drying out too quickly, store them upside down. It'll help keep the moisture in.

 

[Corvs Queen]

Having tried both, I will never, ever use any other gel liner than BB. They are smoother and go on way better. They are creamier and last a long time. Not the Fluidline doesn't last. It's just that I get a lot of skipping and tugging with Fluidline that I don't with BB. Hope that helps some.

 

[zeroxstar]

It's iffy to me cause the MAC one is easier to use and doesn't dry as fast, and i feel it stays on the lids as long.. but it cracks out and dries fast then the BB which lasts me forever, so i dunno.. i go back & forth between the two.

 

[SweetCheeks]

Bobbi Brown hands down. I use Chocolate Shimmer Ink.