Ok I'm a total neutral skank. Here's my list of favorites:
Shroom
Phloof!
Retrospeck
Vanilla
Nylon (this is like Phloof!, has a frosty tone but it's perfect for me for highlighting)
Next to Nothing (this e/s is an LE product, but they sometimes release it in eyeshadow quads. It's definitely a must have!)
Bronze
Woodwinked
All That Glitters
Satin Taupe
Honeylust
I realize that a lot of my neutral favs have shimmer to them, but to me, the above is what I need to pull off a perfect neutral eye. I love neutral looks and to me, the above colors are my favorites, hands down
ALL of these are great, wonderful, fantastic shadows...BUT the ones that (in my opinion) are cannot-live-without MAC shadows are *asterisked*. Hopefully this will help you pick some great stuff!!
PS: Although I know Coppering isn't technically a neutral (I guess mayyybe it could be considered neutral-ish, though), I would reaaaaly reccomend this one..It's fantastic..And, it's a Veluxe Pearl...and VP's are the cat's meow..SO blendable and creamy!!!
I'm definitely going to expand on the ones I have, however, my faves:
Naked Lunch
All that glitters
Jest
Then some others that I like and have:
Satin taupe
woodwinked
femme fi
sumptous olive - not technically a neutral but great with other neutrals
goldmine