Aromaleigh has never changed on me but it is a mineral powder.
Almay Amazing lasting has also stayed true to color.
Lorac oil free, Make Up For Ever Mat Velvet, Lola Oil free, and
Garden Botanika natural balance have all stayed true to color on me.
If you click on the names for Aromaleigh and Garden Botanika it will take you to their site and they both sell samples.
Just a heads up Aromaleigh is closed for business until the 11/13 (order placing will start back up on the 14th). Nothing wrong with the company just that the owner has some things to take care of.
They do ship fast and you can get 3 free e/s samples when you check out.