What are you looking for in a mascara? I find that reviewing mascara based upon application on others is difficult, because each person applies the product differantly, and each person's lashes are so differant that mascara doesn't appear the same on each person wearing the same mascara.
There are a few FOTDs that I've posted where I'm wearing the shu basic, and you can see my un-mascara'd lashes in the tutorial I recently posted.