I pair mine with Cloudburst or Blue Storm Eyeshadows from the same collection. You can pair it with silvers, grey, indigo's, blues, and Mystery Kohl Power (Same collection). I would try Graphology, Blue Noir, Deep Truth, Print, Goldmine, Carbon, Romp, Mulch and Amber Lights. All of these are permanent so you don't have to feel pressured to find them, although I think Blue Noir has been discontinued. I hope this helps! I find that if you don't know what to pair together, get out your collection and hold your items of choice next to various things and see what pops, or you can always go to maccosmetics.com and do a live chat. They are pretty helpful there. (My personal fave is Jara!) Good luck!!