The store actually uses the guy's scent. I would get 8. I think Classic is too much, for that price you might as well get Ruehl's ($20 more), their female fragrance is fabulous. And I think it's more potent too. When my manager would wear Ruehl I could smell him all day. Not so much tho with Abercrombie's fiece. Have you ever smelled "ready"? If you live near an outlet I think it's 15.90 now. I think it's the best female fragrance of the A&F company.