Are NYX e/s the same size as Urban Decay's? Can I fill a NYX palette with UD e/s?

[appleblossm]

I have 5 Urban Decay shadows that I would like put together in a palette and I found out that NYX carries 5-pan filled palettes for $8.

So can I empty out the NYX eyshadows and fill them with my UD ones? If they do fit, what all do I need? Does it need to be magnetized? How do I do that?
Thanks very much for helping a newbie!

​

 

[tara1012]

It SHOULD fit. I don't have that specific palette, but I do have some of the NYX trios and they are the same size as MAC and Urban Decay eye shadows. They fit into the MAC palettes. I would assume those are the same size.

I have no idea how easy/hard it would be to depot the NYX shadows without destroying the palette though.

 

[InspiredBlue]

Yea, it will probably be problematic to get the existing eyeshadows and pans out without breaking the plastic.

Maybe you could fit five pans into this four pan palette, it you rip out the divider? Coastal Scents: 4 pcs Empty Magnetic Palette

 

[kdd2411]

I was wondering the same thing.

 

[xmakeupfanaticx]

Yeah, I think they are the same size, but I had taken some NYX shadows out of a trio a while ago and I think I pretty much tore up the pallette in the process. They might be hard to get out while leaving the pallette in good shape.