Can anyone compare Shade & Existential?

[alt629]

I haven't seen Shade in person. Pics remind me of existential, although maybe it's a bit greyer. Anyone know?

 

[mspixieears]

Shade is supposed to be a dark forest green and Existential is I guess a liquid version of Plumage e/s with more green. Everyone says there's green in Plumage, but I don't see it.

 

[Sprout]

I have Shade, but can't compare it to the other. All I can say is that Shade is a deep dark teal shade. I don't find it to be forrest green, but some do. It would be the greener side of teal, not a bluish teal, if that helps.

 

[Juneplum]

ohhh no hon it's NOTHING like existential.. shade is a dark forest green kinda like tarnish eye kohl in a fluidline.. existential paint is a DARK grey bordering on smoky black color..i have them both.. lemme know if u want me to take a pic of them beside each other for you...

 

[eyeshadowfreak]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Juneplum ohhh no hon it's NOTHING like existential.. shade is a dark forest green kinda like tarnish eye kohl in a fluidline.. existential paint is a DARK grey bordering on smoky black color..i have them both.. lemme know if u want me to take a pic of them beside each other for you...

I kinda have to disagree on your comparison of Shade to Tarnish e/k, Juneplum. On me, Tarnish is a blackened green and Shade is more hunter green with a touch of blue.

 

[Juneplum]

Quote:

Originally Posted by eyeshadowfreak Quote: Originally Posted by Juneplum ohhh no hon it's NOTHING like existential.. shade is a dark forest green kinda like tarnish eye kohl in a fluidline.. existential paint is a DARK grey bordering on smoky black color..i have them both.. lemme know if u want me to take a pic of them beside each other for you... I kinda have to disagree on your comparison of Shade to Tarnish e/k, Juneplum. On me, Tarnish is a blackened green and Shade is more hunter green with a touch of blue.

hmm! hey that's cool!!! on me, shade looks like dark greenish black kinda like how tarnish looks on me!!

it doesn't show any blue on me at all!!!

 

[eyeshadowfreak]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Juneplum Quote: Originally Posted by eyeshadowfreak Quote: Originally Posted by Juneplum ohhh no hon it's NOTHING like existential.. shade is a dark forest green kinda like tarnish eye kohl in a fluidline.. existential paint is a DARK grey bordering on smoky black color..i have them both.. lemme know if u want me to take a pic of them beside each other for you... I kinda have to disagree on your comparison of Shade to Tarnish e/k, Juneplum. On me, Tarnish is a blackened green and Shade is more hunter green with a touch of blue. hmm! hey that's cool!!! on me, shade looks like dark greenish black kinda like how tarnish looks on me!! it doesn't show any blue on me at all!!!

that interesting! I've always known that skin tone made a difference in how different colors look on different people, but this is kinda cool!

 

[alt629]

thanks guys!!!