Can I get opinions on these pigments please?

[Purrple]

They're from different sellers, I have a Sweet Sienna sample from allcosmeticswholesale and Pastorale sample from thebeautysampler, both match (though I've been staring at Pastorale for so long, I'm starting to see things), but the jars seem different. :/ The writing on Pastorale is a bit thicker and positioned higher than on Sweet Sienna.

Sorry for the crappy cell phone pics

Don't trust the colors and the jars aren't really crazy-distorted as they look in the pics.

Thank you so much!

 

[LMD84]

both look ok to me

 

[angi]

They both look ok to me, from your photos and comparisons with my sweet sienna and pastorale, which I know are real. I'd like to see some closer photos of the box for sweet sienna though, as it seems like it might be off.

Marusia - I'd be interested in knowing what distinguishes these as fake for you. Can you PM me too? Thanks!

 

[marusia]

PM'ed you Angi.

 

[LMD84]

Quote:

Originally Posted by angi They both look ok to me, from your photos and comparisons with my sweet sienna and pastorale, which I know are real. I'd like to see some closer photos of the box for sweet sienna though, as it seems like it might be off. Marusia - I'd be interested in knowing what distinguishes these as fake for you. Can you PM me too? Thanks!

yeah it looks prettymuch like my sweet sienna too which i got from a cco back in 2008. sadly i don't own a full size of pastoral but the packaging looks ok to me.

 

[Purrple]

Thanks, guys

The weird thing about Sweet Sienna - the jar looks so fake, but the pigment itself is EXACTLY like the sample from ACW. And Sweet Sienna is a very complex shade! lol, I read other threads where people said it stained blue and thought wtf, mine never does that. Then I tried it on my hand with a mixing medium and it left a faint blue stain. 0_0


ETA: Oh, and I'll get closer pics tomorrow! Today I only have my cell phone available. :/