MAC frost lipsticks need recs, please!

[solarkitty]

Hi,

I'm a C40/C5. I'm looking for more neutral/golden/metallic and not red/too pink shades.
I have: Shitaki, Frenzy, Chintz, Coconutty, O, Bronze Shimmer.

Would a shade like Icon be too cool for me - same goes for the violet in 3-D?
And would Gel, Strength and Plastique be too light?
Any opinions on Fetish for darker complexions?


Any other recs, in frost or other versions?

Thanks in advance for any replies.

 

[moopoint]

I love Tanarama, it's my new fav at the moment. It seems to fit your description. Frost, neutral/golden/metallic. Give it a try!

 

[panda0410]

Archetype from McQueen would be perfect! Or Quiet please

I have them both and love them! But if you want truly golden sparkle then try Voile slimshine - this is AMAZING - I LOVE it!!

 

[Mizz.Coppertone]

Fetish is beautiful! Def get it. Top it with Oh Baby lipglass, it looks so sexy and shimmery!