Recommendations for highlighter for Woodwinked?

[pinkbutterflies]

Hi, I recently discovered Woodwinked and really love it! I use it on my lid with Bronze in the crease. I bought Retrospeck for the highlighter, but I'm finding now it's too shimmery, especially when paired with Woodwinked although I love the colour. Does anyone have any recommendations for something else I could use as highlighter that's around the same tone but not as shimmery? Also, if anyone has any other recommendations for a crease shadow that would work well with Woodwinked I'd love to hear them!

(For reference, I'm Asian and C35 in foundation with dark brown eyes).

Thanks in advance for any help anyone could give!

 

[MAC is love]

I use shroom, it's a nice color with no shimmer in it.

 

[me_jelly]

I would have to agree with both above posts - shroom for less shimmery highlight, and ricepaper for more of a shimmery finish

 

[pinkbutterflies]

Thanks so much for the recommendations! I have heard a lot of people recommend Mulch with Woodwinked so I'll have to try that out! Ricepaper looked a bit white on me when I tried it on (I have a bit darker skin than most being Asian), but maybe if I blended it it could work better.

Thanks again!

 

[TIERAsta]

I agree with shroom. Woodwinked, mulch, and shroom is one of my favorite combos ever!!

 

[SnowWhiteQueen]

I like using provence pigment as a highlight, woodwinked on the lid, and satin taupe in the crease.

 

[user79]

Another vote for Shroom. I actually think Jest looks gorgeous with it, it has a champagne pink tone, but it's also shimmery.

 

[Jess-ee-ka]

Try Shroom, its the perfect satin finish. Not too shimmery. I also like Nylon but its pretty frosty. Vanilla Pigment is beautiful with that golden tone. Fairylite is a nice, not too shimmery highlight. And also you could try Benefit High Brow which is just like an all-purpose brow highlight (no shimmer). The bonus: it makes you look like you just had a brow lift. Haha