Shimpagne V.S. Soft and Gentle

[Cherrymint]

Hey Everyone! Just curious as to how Shimpagne MSF and Soft and Gentle MSF differ? according to the MAC website: Shimpagne is a "Vintage gold gilded beige" while Soft And Gentle is a "Gilded peach bronze". I missed out on Shimpagne

...but I have Soft and Gentle and I love it. Does anyone have any swatches of them together or can anyone tell me if they are similar to each other?

Thanks!

 

[purplerinne]

I have Shimpagne but didn't get S&G bc it was TOO close.....so I think if you have one u don't need the other

 

[TISH1124]

I LOVE Shimpagne.....they are similar to me color wise in the pan...but the feel of Shimpagne is so great....It is more finely milled like the BBR MSF's....I have S&G and it's just Okay to me

 

[kariii]

Shimpagne formulation is better than Soft & gentle.. soft and gentle is kinda chunky glittery.

 

[gildedangel]

They look exactly the same on me. I personally like the texture of my S&G, I don't find it to be chunky or glittery in the least! I feel like Shimpagne has bigger chunks of glitter, but that's just my opinion.

 

[Cherrymint]

Thanks so much guys!!!

you all were very helpful!