Too Face vs Urban Decay

[diva32472]

When it comes to mac eye shadow what is your preference for a base I am still unsure between insurance and primer potion

 

[MrsRjizzle]

They both do the same job. Shadow insurance makes more sense to me. The packaging makes it easier to use and I feel like it is more value for your money.

Just imo...

 

[SweetCheeks]

You might enjoy this vid:

YouTube - Too Faced Shadow Insurance vs. Urban Decay Primer Potion

 

[MiCHiE]

Shadow Insurance is not as ashy as PP.

 

[mizuki~]

Most people who've tried both liked Shadow Insurance better. I'm using UDPP but it still creases and fades for me. Can't wait to finish the UDPP so I can try out TFSI

 

[starangel2383]

sounds like something i will need to try out.

 

[FiestyFemme]

Honestly, I think I like UD PP better. I think it's a bit drier than TF SI, and so PP tended to hold up better on my oily lids throughout the day. TF SI isn't bad, but for me, UD PP has a slight edge over it. I'm using TF while I wait for UD to re-package the PP, but once they do, I'm definitely going back.

 

[gigiopolis]

You'll like UDPP more if you have very oily lids. Which I do. UDPP's anti-creasing power is WAY better. If you have dry lids though use Shadow Insurance.

 

[xoleaxo]

i prefer UDPP.. it seems creamier in texture and it dries faster. Too Faced Shadow Insurance was thinner and felt more slippery.

Honestly, they both work and do what they are supposed to.. maybe you can go to Sephora and get a sample of them both.

 

[enjoybeingagirl]

I don't like UDPP - I have used up a whole tube and it isn't nearly as effective as Too Faced Shadow Insurance or BE Primetime For Eyes. I have dry skin so that could be the problem.