I agree with
aziajs, I haven't met a pink I didn't like either.
You have to have a nicely prepped canvas on the eye if the color isn't showing up on you. UDPP, paint pot, shadestick, etc for base is ideal, esp. for lighter pinks.
I own Scene 1, Girlie, Sushi Flower, and Naked Lunch from MAC, and Summer Sunset from Origins. I think I may have some more, but those are the ones I can recall now.
Oh, and if you pack the shadow on with a brush like #239 (I have the SK brush like it) rather than sweep the shadow on, you'll get better payoff. I personally think darker skins were made for color, esp. pink.
Good luck
Edit: I think the formula of the shadow can determine how easy v. how difficult the payoff will be, too. Scene 1's velvet texture took me a minute to figure out, but Girlie glides/packs on easily.