MAC and Gareth Pugh Discussion

internetchick

Well-known member
I finally went back to see what the other 2 nail polishes look like and I'm not impressed at all. IMO totally dupable and not worth $23.
Agreed. I had been following the news about this because the polish in the bottles looks out of this world, but they just didn't translate well to the nail. Too bad, because I would have bought all 3 if they had.
 

Adee

Well-known member
I'm actually really digging the packaging here. I rarely get into the couture collections because I don't have a fs store up here and I generally hate buying without testing. But this collection might change that for me. The only thing I'm not excited about is the lipgloss packaging. I've never been a fan of the square tubes. They're so hard to get anything out of!
 

Mac-Guy

Well-known member
I'm actually really digging the packaging here. I rarely get into the couture collections because I don't have a fs store up here and I generally hate buying without testing. But this collection might change that for me. The only thing I'm not excited about is the lipgloss packaging. I've never been a fan of the square tubes. They're so hard to get anything out of!

Yes, it will last forever. Lol.

I still BU-ed Vacant though...
 

LMD84

Well-known member
I'd say get them. I really like the piggies for their texture and the color pay-off, especially if you use both in the same look. On my skin, Guise swatches as a very light silver and I have nothing that comes close to it. It is a nice color for a subtle smokey eye that will look stunning on pale skin, especially if you wear it with a vampy lip.

Deceit is much more burgundy than purple on me, with the purple coming more as a sheen whereas the base seems to be a true burgundy. IMO, it's rather unique and I don't think it looks like deep purple.

For reference, I'm NW20 (maybe closer to 15-18 during this time of the year), so the colors might look different on other complexions.

The only drawback is the smaller size, but piggies are usually the only product that I do not BU as I haven't finished any yet (except for perm colors). Happy shopping.
and you have sold me on both again! :) thanks! i shall be buying both piggies and the nude lippie. then i shall get my strada as a pro pan :)
 

Mac-Guy

Well-known member

Can't wait to see a FOTD/look.
flower.gif
 

singer82

Well-known member
I am really loving the look of Vacant l/g. And I love the gloss packaging so I'm def getting that!
I also want Ascension n/l. I love silver/grey nails, I love that this one is a softer silver/grey than a lot of n/p's I get in this color family. Not to mention the subtle purple and green in it. Plus I love the bottle. And I think it's different enough from wicked game and greys anatomy. I dont always not get something just because theres a dupe, theres always slight differences. Hyper is pretty but I have Orlys Lunar Eclipse so I'm good with that.

Everything else is passable. I dunno, I thought I'd want more, but I really am trying to only get stuff I know I'm going to wear. And that I really really want. I already have Strada, but I use the blush a lot so I wouldnt mind having a BU. Plus I really want something with the compact packaging. But I'll have to wait to get it with the holidays and everything, hopefully it will still be around.
 

wishonastar

Well-known member
Skip... Overpriced and nothing amazing looking. A lot is dupeable too, maybe not exactly but enough. The purple pigment looks like a bruise IMO so that is a no go for me, I have enough purple around my eyes as it is. The nail polishes are disappointing to me, I don't see enough duochrome in them to bother paying that much. I've got so many bottles of polish that I can't justify buying something I don't love any more. Plus there is no guarantee that I am going to have a job next month, my company is making redundancies in two weeks...
 

PeachTwist

Well-known member
I'm LOVING the look of Strada - not loving the price. -- I'm apparently NC15 -- will this be more of a contour shade or a blush shade? (I'm not bothered either way, just curious!)

I keep being told it's discontinued, and then I get told it's available to buy from the PRO shop if you call and order it?

Can anyone in the UK tell me which it is as I seriously do not want to buy it in this packaging for less product.

Also, sounds silly - but can someone give me the number for MAC Pro over here? I'm moving this week so I can say bye-bye to my internet until Dec. 12th and would like to make sure I have the number to call and order it lol!
 

wishonastar

Well-known member
I'm LOVING the look of Strada - not loving the price. -- I'm apparently NC15 -- will this be more of a contour shade or a blush shade? (I'm not bothered either way, just curious!)

I keep being told it's discontinued, and then I get told it's available to buy from the PRO shop if you call and order it?

Can anyone in the UK tell me which it is as I seriously do not want to buy it in this packaging for less product.

Also, sounds silly - but can someone give me the number for MAC Pro over here? I'm moving this week so I can say bye-bye to my internet until Dec. 12th and would like to make sure I have the number to call and order it lol!
I'm unsure if it is available at PRO over here, I would assume that it is though. I might go to the PRO store on Saturday and check. This is what it says on the website for Mail Order:
Mail Order - To place your order over the phone you can call MAC Mail Order on 0870 034 2676. Opening Hours 9am to 6pm Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm Saturday . Excluding public holidays.
 

rubytitania

Well-known member
I'm relieved that so far nothing has grabbed me. I might actually end up being able to skip this collection completely which would be awesome for my finances!
 

xasperadastra

Well-known member
I am really loving the look of Vacant l/g. And I love the gloss packaging so I'm def getting that!
I also want Ascension n/l. I love silver/grey nails, I love that this one is a softer silver/grey than a lot of n/p's I get in this color family. Not to mention the subtle purple and green in it. Plus I love the bottle. And I think it's different enough from wicked game and greys anatomy. I dont always not get something just because theres a dupe, theres always slight differences. Hyper is pretty but I have Orlys Lunar Eclipse so I'm good with that.

Everything else is passable. I dunno, I thought I'd want more, but I really am trying to only get stuff I know I'm going to wear. And that I really really want. I already have Strada, but I use the blush a lot so I wouldnt mind having a BU. Plus I really want something with the compact packaging. But I'll have to wait to get it with the holidays and everything, hopefully it will still be around.

That's the point! I really love the packaging... but Am I going to use a pale lipstick? Things that I really like are:
strada but it's a third of the product T___T
deceit half of the produt
inert

Lipglasses are cute. Now I think I should go for Elude (although the price) because maybe I can refill it once is finished (I can't do that with strada)... I still have to see swatches. I'm afraid to regret missing the packaging of lips stuff... but I won't use them so often to justify the price!!
 

Anitacska

Well-known member
The only thing I might get is the light purple lipglass, but even that's a maybe. I'll just get the Deborah Lippmann nail polish and skip the others since I have Orly Lunar Eclipse (and the DL one is 15 ml instead of 9 ml for pretty much the same price by the looks of it). Or maybe just get the Wet n Wild dupe for a lot less money. ;)
 

princess sarah

Well-known member
He is good like that isnt he!!!!! hahahaha

Im still really keen on the Vacant Lipglass and the Restrict Lipstick. I know they wont sell out this close to christmas so im thinking of taking my chances and waiting until Xmas is done and then grabbing one of these. If I was to choose 1 of these products then it would have to be the Restrict Lipstick. There are no CCO over here in Australia where I live so its a matter of timing the purchase correctly... grr but I want it now... decisions decisions!!!

But I know me... if im undecided like this, chances are, I will just buy it and not wait
queen.gif


My strada blush in pro pan is already sorted and my brush is the only thing that I have ordered from my 'Mac Lady'

 

wishonastar

Well-known member
The only thing I might get is the light purple lipglass, but even that's a maybe. I'll just get the Deborah Lippmann nail polish and skip the others since I have Orly Lunar Eclipse (and the DL one is 15 ml instead of 9 ml for pretty much the same price by the looks of it). Or maybe just get the Wet n Wild dupe for a lot less money. ;)
I liked the light purple lipglass but I have Docile which is similar although not as purple. I don't need this one, it is just a waste to buy it for me as I wear lipstick way more than gloss. That was the only thing I liked from this collection. I'd rather save money for Iris, Daphne and the new MSFs/MES.

Do you know if we can get Wet n Wild in the UK? I've looked before but with no luck... other than Ebay.
 

Anitacska

Well-known member
Ugh, I think you're right, I have Docile too and never use it. Maybe I'll skip then.

I don't think we get Wet n Wild in the UK, sadly.

I liked the light purple lipglass but I have Docile which is similar although not as purple. I don't need this one, it is just a waste to buy it for me as I wear lipstick way more than gloss. That was the only thing I liked from this collection. I'd rather save money for Iris, Daphne and the new MSFs/MES.
Do you know if we can get Wet n Wild in the UK? I've looked before but with no luck... other than Ebay.
 
Top