MAC Extra Dimension discussion

pemily

Well-known member
Does Havana e/s look like Glorify EDSF and Sweet Heat e/s look like Superb EDSF?

the havana I can remember, even the SA said "im going to write this down LOL", they were a splitting image, she also said why bother buying both.... I'm all for buying everything but I don't often get to see items before I order them from the US so why waste money when they are identical products... I mean IDENTICAL!!
 

PixieDancer

Well-known member
On the TC thread you are a Goddess...
On THIS thread you are a Temptress! HeeHee
Can't wait to see your swatches as I IMPATIENTLY wait for my Pro order to arrive!
Thanks!!


 

Shellcat

Well-known member
Lol!!!

Yes, I will swatch these tomorrow. Three collections at once has my head spinning...wait...is that the cocktails or the excitement over this collection?!?!
yahoo.gif



 

pemily

Well-known member
I'm actually surprised that no one else has mentioned it yet that has seen/swatched... Like I said they Looked the same but I wasn't allowed to swatch....... If they look identical in the pan I would assume they would swatch alike...
 

Shellcat

Well-known member
Ok...couldn't sleep. Decided to check these out.

Here are my swatches:
Left to right:
Sweet Heat e/s vs. Superb Highlighter <-----These two as you can see are a PERFECT match! And a GORGEOUS color, BTW...
Next is Havana and Glorify. Not so much... Havana is a brown bronzy shade on me and Glorify is very copper/gold-toned.






Does Havana e/s look like Glorify EDSF and Sweet Heat e/s look like Superb EDSF?
 

Baby1black

Well-known member
Ok...couldn't sleep.  Decided to check these out.
 
Here are my swatches:
Left to right:
Sweet Heat e/s vs. Superb Highlighter <-----These two as you can see are a PERFECT match! And a GORGEOUS color, BTW...
Next is Havana and Glorify.  Not so much... Havana is a brown bronzy shade on me and Glorify is very copper/gold-toned.
 
 

 


 
Very nice can not wait for the rest. How do u like glorify?
 

Piarpreet

Well-known member
all tres cheek blushes, heroine, pink popcorn, Whisper of guilt, split fiber cheek brush, studio fix fluid, clear brow set gel, supersweet MES, reflect pink glitter. I'm broke now.... And I want more... I think i might get watch me simmer, but there is a chance by the time i get it (I hate paying for shipping u know that...so it will have to wait for another order) it will be gone. Maybe if I see it in Madrid and I love it I might get it. I wonder when reel sexy will come out in Spain.
What did you get so far?
 

Catatonia

Well-known member
Wow Superb looks sooooo pretty on that swatch
heart.gif
Just looking at it makes me want to buy it even though lately I'm not a huge fan of frosty stuff on my cheeks (I even decided Full of Joy blush isn't what I want and need).

*I don't need it, don't need it, don't need it*
 

strbuks77

Well-known member
So I seriously sat in front of my computer for 2 hours trying to decide what I wanted from this collection, I had decided on whisper of gilt, and glorify definitely, then the more I looked at superb, the more it grew on me. I really only had money for 2 SF's. If I wanted to get all the eyeshadows that I wanted. After 2 almost 3 hours and staring at the computer, and my family looking at me like I had completely lost my senses. I decided on, ALL three SF. I just HAD to get them! I didn't want to be kicking myself later after its sold out. Plus everyone keeps saying the texture is to die for, and I didn't want to miss out. Then the eyeshadows I got were: Blue Orbit, Grand Galaxy, Young Venus, & Modern Pewter. I really wanted Rich core, & Warm Thunder, but I had to cut something to get all three of those SF. I am happy with what I ordered, even if my sanity has come into question. lol!!
 

martiangurll

Well-known member
Hope I am not gonna regret skipping Modern Pewter and Havana. Oh well. I will just rub my BU of Hocus Pocus and say, "My Precious" a few times and get that out of my system...
 

Mac-Guy

Well-known member
Hope I am not gonna regret skipping Modern Pewter and Havana. Oh well. I will just rub my BU of Hocus Pocus and say, "My Precious" a few times and get that out of my system...

Honey, I don't want to enable you, but you can't skip MP and H.
 

Mac-Guy

Well-known member
WOO HOO!

You confirmed what I suspected. I bought the three EDSF b/c I planned on doing the entire face- including eyes too - with them.

I also plan on doing some lip glosses too.

I am so glad you confirmed my suspicions about the e/s being similar.

The SF and e/s formula is slightly different, not so much in color (though there are still noticeable differences), but more in how they wear on the lid. The e/s definitely last longer on the lids than the SF's. But give it a try, maybe it works for you. Let us know.
 

Colorqueen

Well-known member
So I seriously sat in front of my computer for 2 hours trying to decide what I wanted from this collection, I had decided on whisper of gilt, and glorify definitely, then the more I looked at superb, the more it grew on me. I really only had money for 2 SF's. If I wanted to get all the eyeshadows that I wanted. After 2 almost 3 hours and staring at the computer, and my family looking at me like I had completely lost my senses. I decided on, ALL three SF. I just HAD to get them! I didn't want to be kicking myself later after its sold out. Plus everyone keeps saying the texture is to die for, and I didn't want to miss out. Then the eyeshadows I got were: Blue Orbit, Grand Galaxy, Young Venus, & Modern Pewter. I really wanted Rich core, & Warm Thunder, but I had to cut something to get all three of those SF. I am happy with what I ordered, even if my sanity has come into question. lol!!

HAHAHA Sounds just like I wrote this! I did the same thing and my family is like, "It's JUST makeup"
 

Colorqueen

Well-known member
I wear MSF on the eyes all of the time, so I imagine this will be fine. I use them when I want to go for a natural look- to enhance skin appearance, not necessarily wear eyeshadow colors- does that make sense? I will def let you know if it works. :)
 

Colorqueen

Well-known member

WOW- I wish I had not seen this. Now I want Havana to use on my face with the EDSF! It would make the PERFECT contour.
 
Top